Enoch Powell: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added
Early years: Capitalising Church
Departure from the Conservative Party: Also added information on the Stroud “Powell Conservative” candidate
Tags: Mobile edit Mobile web edit Advanced mobile edit
 
(10 intermediate revisions by 8 users not shown)
Line 73:
 
== Early years ==
John Enoch Powell was born in [[Stechford]], Warwickshire, within the city of [[Birmingham]], on 16 June 1912, and was baptised at [[Newport, Shropshire|Newport]], Shropshire, in [[St Nicholas Church, Newport|St Nicholas's Church]], where his parents had married in 1909.<ref>{{cite news|title=Controversial MP's family links and childhood memories of the [Shropshire] county|work=Shropshire Star|date=15 April 2021|page=16}}Report by Toby Neal.</ref> He was the only child of Albert Enoch Powell, a primary school headmaster, and his wife, Ellen Mary. Ellen was the daughter of Henry Breese, a [[Liverpool]] policeman, and his wife Eliza, who had been a teacher. His mother did not like his name, and as a child he was known as "Jack".{{sfn|Shepherd|1997|p=5}} At the age of three, Powell was nicknamed "the Professor" because he used to stand on a chair and describe the stuffed birds that his grandfather had shot, which were displayed in his parents' home.{{sfn|Shepherd|1997|p=3}} In 1918, the family moved to [[Kings Norton]], Birmingham, where Powell remained until 1930.
 
The Powells were of [[Welsh people|Welsh]] descent and from [[Radnorshire]] (a Welsh border county), having moved to the developing [[Black Country]] during the early 19th century. His great-grandfather was a [[coal miner]], and his grandfather had been in the iron trade.<ref name="Roth">Roth.</ref>
Line 129:
Powell was appointed Secretary to the Joint Intelligence Committee for India and [[Lord Louis Mountbatten]]'s [[South East Asia]] Command,{{sfn|Shepherd|1997|p=50}} involved in planning an amphibious offensive against [[Akyab]], an island off the coast of Burma. [[Orde Wingate]], also involved in planning that operation, had taken such a dislike to Powell that he asked a colleague to restrain him if he were tempted to "beat his brains in".{{sfn|Shepherd|1997|p=54}}
 
On one occasion, Powell's yellow skin (he was recovering from [[jaundice]]), over-formal dress and strange manner caused him to be mistaken for a Japanese spy.{{sfn|Heffer|1998|p=83}} During this period, he declined to meet a Cambridge academic colleague, [[Glyn Daniel]], for a drink or dinner as he was devoting his limited leisure time to studying the poet [[John Donne]].{{sfn|Shepherd|1997|p=52}} Powell had continued to learn Urdu and was taught by a nephew of the Urdu poet [[Altaf Hussain Hali]]. He had an unrealised ambition to compose a critical edition of Hali's [[Musaddas]], ''The Rise and Fall of Islam''.{{sfn|Heffer|1998|p=87}} He also had an ambition of eventually becoming [[Viceroy of India]], and when Mountbatten transferred his staff to [[Kandy]], [[British Ceylon|Ceylon]], Powell chose to remain in Delhi. He was promoted to full colonel at the end of March 1944, as assistant director of military intelligence in India, giving intelligence support to the [[Burma]] campaign of [[Sir William Slim]].{{sfn|Heffer|1998|p=93}}
 
Having begun the war as the youngest professor in the British Empire, Powell ended it as a [[Brigadier (United Kingdom)|brigadier]]. He was given the promotion to serve on a committee of generals and brigadiers to plan the postwar defence of India: the resulting 470-page report was almost entirely written by Powell. For a few weeks he was the youngest brigadier in the British Army,{{sfn|Heffer|1998|p=93}} and he was one of only two men in the entire war to rise from private to brigadier (the other being [[Sir Fitzroy Maclean, 1st Baronet|Sir Fitzroy Maclean]]). He was offered a regular commission as a brigadier in the Indian Army, and the post of assistant commandant of an Indian officers' training academy, which he declined.{{sfn|Heffer|1998|p=97}} He told a colleague that he expected to be head of all military intelligence in "the next war".{{sfn|Shepherd|1997|p=54}}
Line 198:
After his speech on immigration in 1968, Powell's political opponents sometimes alleged that he had, when Minister of Health, recruited immigrants from the Commonwealth into the [[National Health Service]] (NHS). However, the Minister of Health was not responsible for recruitment (this was left to health authorities){{sfn|Heffer|1998|p=286}} and [[Sir George Godber]], [[Chief Medical Officer (United Kingdom)|Chief Medical Officer]] for Her Majesty's Government in [[England]] from 1960 to 1973 (and for [[England and Wales]] from 1960 to 1969), stated that the allegation was "bunk&nbsp;... absolute rubbish. There was no such policy".{{sfn|Heffer|1998|p=597}} Powell's biographer [[Simon Heffer]] also stated that the claim "is a complete untruth. As Powell's biographer I have been thoroughly through the Ministry of Health papers at the Public Record Office and have found no evidence to support this assertion".<ref>''The Times'' (17 February 1998), p. 21.</ref>
 
During the early 1960s, Powell was asked about the recruitment of immigrant workers for the NHS. He replied by saying "recruitment was in the hands of the hospital authorities, but this was something that happened of its own accord given that there was no bar upon entry and employment in the United Kingdom to those from the West Indies or anywhere else [in the Commonwealth or colonies]."<ref name=immigration1>{{cite book|title=Enoch Powell: A Biography|last=Shepherd|first=Robert|chapter=Hypocrite on immigration?|pages=222–226}}</ref> Powell did welcome immigrant nurses and doctors, under the condition that they were to be temporary workers training in the UK and would then return to their native countries as qualified doctors or nurses.<ref name=immigration1 /> Shortly after becoming Minister of Health, Powell asked Rab Butler (the [[Home Secretary]]) if he could be appointed to a ministerial committee which monitored immigration and was about to be re-constituted.<ref name=immigration1 /> Powell was worried about the strain caused by NHS immigrants, and papers show that he wanted a stronger restriction on Commonwealth immigration than whatthat which was passed in 1961.<ref name=immigration1 />
 
== 1960s ==
Line 283:
The Conservatives had promised at the 1970 general election<ref>{{cite web | work = Politics Resources | url = http://www.politicsresources.net/area/uk/man/con70.htm | title = Not updated: British Conservative Party election manifesto | orig-year = 1970 | publisher = Keele | location = UK | date = 11 March 2008 | access-date = 10 August 2009 | archive-url = https://web.archive.org/web/20100110125744/http://www.politicsresources.net/area/uk/man/con70.htm | archive-date = 10 January 2010 | url-status = dead }}</ref> in relation to the Common Market. "Our sole commitment is to negotiate; no more, no less". The second reading of the Bill to put the Treaty into law was passed by just eight votes on second reading, and Powell declared his hostility to his party's line. He voted against the government on every one of the 104 divisions in the course of the European Communities Bill. When Britain finally entered the EEC in January 1973, after three years of campaigning on the question, he decided he could no longer sit in a parliament that he believed was no longer sovereign.
 
A ''[[Daily Express]]'' opinion poll in 1972 showed Powell to be the most popular politician in the country.<ref name="alor"/> In mid-1972, he prepared to resign the Conservative whip and changed his mind only because of fears of a renewed wave of immigration from Uganda after the accession of [[Idi Amin]], who had expelled Uganda's Asian residents. He decided to remain in parliament and in the Conservative Party, and was expected to support the party in Wolverhampton at the [[February 1974 United Kingdom general election|snap general election of February 1974]] called by [[Edward Heath]]. However, on 23 February 1974, with the election only five days away, Powell dramatically turned his back on his party, giving as the reasons that it had taken the United Kingdom into the EEC without having a mandate to do so, and that it had abandoned other manifesto commitments, so that he could no longer support it at the election.<ref>{{Citation|url=https://www.expressandstar.com/days/1950-75/1974.html |title=1974 |work=Express & Star |url-status=dead |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20120717052230/http://www.expressandstar.com/days/1950-75/1974.html |archive-date=17 July 2012 }}</ref> The monetarist economist [[Milton Friedman]] sent Powell a letter praising him as principled.,{{sfn|Heffer|1998|p=703}} and notably, there was a breakaway faction of the Conservative Party in [[Gloucester (UK Parliament constituency)|Gloucester]] which selected a candidate who stood under the party name of "Powell Conservative", securing 366 votes, 0.7% of the overall vote share in the constituency.<ref>{{cite web |url= http://spprd.insec.netcopy.thompsonjames.co.uk/article/23rd-february-1974/11/1-oucester-a-l-ocal-correspondent-he-intervention-
|title=Reports From the Marginals- Gloucester
|publisher=The Spectator Archive
|access-date=12 October 2024
|df=dmy
}}</ref> There was also a candidate listed in the neighbouring constituency of [[Stroud (UK Parliament constituency)|Stroud]] who obtained 470 votes, 0.8% of the overall vote share in the constituency.
 
Powell had arranged for his friend [[Andrew Alexander (journalist)|Andrew Alexander]] to talk to [[Joe Haines (journalist)|Joe Haines]], the press secretary of the Labour leader [[Harold Wilson]], about the timing of Powell's speeches against Heath. Powell had been talking to Wilson irregularly since June 1973 during chance meetings in the gentlemen's lavatories of the "aye" lobby in the House of Commons.{{sfn|Heffer|1998|pp=701–702}} Wilson and Haines had ensured that Powell would dominate the newspapers of the Sunday and Monday before election day by having no Labour frontbencher give a major speech on 23 February, the day of Powell's speech.{{sfn|Heffer|1998|pp=704–705}} Powell gave this speech at the Mecca Dance Hall in the [[Bull Ring, Birmingham|Bull Ring]], Birmingham, to an audience of 1,500, with some press reports estimating that 7,000 more had to be turned away. Powell said the issue of British membership of the EEC was one where "if there be a conflict between the call of country and that of party, the call of country must come first":
Line 499 ⟶ 504:
During the 1970 election, [[Tony Benn]] declared in a speech that Powell's approach to immigration was 'evil', and said "The flag of racialism which has been hoisted in Wolverhampton is beginning to look like the one that fluttered over [[Dachau]] and [[Belsen]]." In response, when a television reporter told Powell at a meeting of Benn's comments, he snatched the microphone and replied "All I will say is that for myself, in 1939 I voluntarily returned from Australia to this country, to serve as a private soldier against [[Nazi Germany|Germany]] and [[Nazism]]. I am the same man today."<ref>Shepherd 1994, p. 395.</ref> Similarly, Powell responded to student hecklers at a speech in Cardiff: "I hope those who shouted 'Fascist' and 'Nazi' are aware that before they were born I was fighting against Fascism and Nazism."{{sfn|Heffer|1998|p=489}}
 
In November 1968, Powell also suggested that the problems that would be caused if there were a large influx of Germans or Russians into the UK "would be as serious – and in some respects more serious – than could follow from the introduction of a similar number of West Indies or Pakistanis".<ref name="Shepherd 1994, p 365">Shepherd 19941997, p. 365.</ref>
 
Powell said his views were neither genetic nor eugenic, and that he never arranged his fellow men on a merit according to their origins.<ref>Shepherd 1994, pp. 364–365.</ref>