Jump to content

Jesse Singal: Difference between revisions

Add links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous edit
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
m Reverted edit by 95.90.202.191 (talk) to last version by My Pants Metal
Tags: Rollback Reverted
 
(47 intermediate revisions by 23 users not shown)
Line 28: Line 28:


==Biography==
==Biography==
Singal is one of three sons born to Sydney L. (née Altman) (1949–2021) and Bruce A. Singal.<ref>{{Cite news|first= |last= |authorlink= |title= Sydney L. Altman |newspaper=[[The Boston Globe]]|date= April 22, 2021|url= https://www.newspapers.com/clip/104387463/the-boston-globe/ |via=[[Newspapers.com]]}}</ref> Both of his parents were attorneys. He received a master's degree in public affairs from Princeton's [[Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs]].<ref name="about-me"/> He is of [[American Jews|Jewish]] descent<ref>{{Cite news|first1=Chait |last1=Jonathan |first2=Jesse |last2=Singal |authorlink1= Jonathan Chait |title= How Alarmed Should American Jews Be Right Now? Two Jews Kibitz |newspaper=[[New York Magazine]]|date=November 16, 2016 |url= https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2016/11/is-there-a-new-american-antisemitism.html |quote=Two of New York Magazine’s Jewish staffers, Jonathan Chait and Jesse Singal, decided to discuss the question.}}</ref> and lives in [[Brooklyn]].<ref name="substack-about"/>
Singal is one of three sons born to Sydney L. ({{nee|Altman}}; 1949–2021) and Bruce A. Singal.<ref>{{Cite news|first= |last= |authorlink= |title= Sydney L. Altman |newspaper=[[The Boston Globe]]|date= April 22, 2021|url= https://www.newspapers.com/clip/104387463/the-boston-globe/ |via=[[Newspapers.com]]}}</ref> Both of his parents were attorneys. He received a master's degree in public affairs from Princeton's [[Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs]].<ref name="about-me"/> He is of [[American Jews|Jewish]] descent<ref>{{Cite news|first1=Chait |last1=Jonathan |first2=Jesse |last2=Singal |authorlink1= Jonathan Chait |title= How Alarmed Should American Jews Be Right Now? Two Jews Kibitz |newspaper=[[New York Magazine]]|date=November 16, 2016 |url= https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2016/11/is-there-a-new-american-antisemitism.html |quote=Two of New York Magazine’s Jewish staffers, Jonathan Chait and Jesse Singal, decided to discuss the question.}}</ref> and lives in [[Brooklyn]].<ref name="substack-about"/>


==Writing about transgender issues==
==Writing about transgender issues==
⚫
Singal has been described as one of the most prominent journalists working in the area of transgender issues,<ref name="advocate-accountability"/><ref name="jezebel-groupthink"/> though he has also been criticized as writing with an anti-transgender bias.<ref name="GLAAD-accountability"/>

⚫
Singal has been described as one of the most prominent journalists working in the area of transgender issues.<ref name="advocate-accountability"/><ref name="jezebel-groupthink"/> His reporting on [[detransition]] and transition regret has been negatively received by transgender activists.<ref name="advocate-accountability"/><ref name="jezebel-groupthink"/><ref name="advocate-atlantic"/><ref name="nyt-cancel"/>


===2018 ''Atlantic'' article===
===2018 ''Atlantic'' article===
Singal wrote the cover story for the July/August 2018 issue of ''The Atlantic''. Originally published under the title "When a Child Says She's Trans", the online version was later retitled "When Children Say They're Trans". The [[Long-form journalism|long-form]] piece includes profiles of several adolescents who identify or previously identified as transgender, interviews with youth gender clinicians, and reviews of some of the studies, statistics, and protocols related to [[transgender youth|youth transition]]. In a follow-up, ''The Atlantic'' published four letters from parents of transgender children reacting to Singal's article with a mixture of criticism and praise.<ref name="atlantic-parents" /> Alexandria Neason, writing for the ''[[Columbia Journalism Review]]'', stated that despite being fact-checked, the story was considered transphobic by many readers, journalists and activists, and suggested that more diversity in editorial oversight could have averted the problem.<ref name="CJR Fact-checking" />
Singal wrote the cover story for the July/August 2018 issue of ''The Atlantic''. Originally published under the title "When a Child Says She's Trans", the online version was later retitled "When Children Say They're Trans". The [[Long-form journalism|long-form]] piece includes profiles of several adolescents who identify or previously identified as transgender, interviews with youth gender clinicians, and reviews of some of the studies, statistics, and protocols related to [[transgender youth|youth transition]]. In a follow-up, ''The Atlantic'' published four letters from parents of transgender children reacting to Singal's article with a mixture of criticism and praise.<ref name="atlantic-parents" /> Alexandria Neason, writing for the ''[[Columbia Journalism Review]]'', stated that despite being fact-checked, the story was considered transphobic by many readers, journalists and activists, and suggested that more diversity in editorial oversight could have averted the problem.<ref name="CJR Fact-checking" />


Among the controversial aspects of the article was the proportion of weight given to stories of adolescents who had desisted or [[detransition]]ed — that is, reverted to identifying with their genders assigned at birth, either before or after undergoing physical transition. In the article, Singal acknowledges that the stories of detransitioners are sometimes viewed with skepticism or suspicion by the transgender community, in part because they have been used by conservative media to further misleading narratives. Alex Barasch, writing in ''[[Slate (magazine)|Slate]]'', faulted the article for not including the story of "a single happy, well-adjusted trans teen" in its first 9,000 words.<ref name="slate-atlantic" /> However, one of the reader response letters published by ''The Atlantic'' identified in the article two stories of happily transitioned teens, though the author referred to them as being "buried deep in the article".<ref name="atlantic-parents" /> Barasch also criticized Singal for failing to include the stories of individuals who had detransitioned for reasons other than a realization that they were not trans, such as social stigma.<ref name="slate-atlantic" /> Some transgender advocates questioned whether it was appropriate for a [[cisgender]] man like Singal, rather than a transgender writer, to write on the topic.<ref name="economist-trans"/>
Among the controversial aspects of the article was the proportion of weight given to stories of adolescents who had desisted or [[detransition]]ed—that is, reverted to identifying with their genders assigned at birth, either before or after undergoing physical transition. In the article, Singal acknowledges that the stories of detransitioners are sometimes viewed with skepticism or suspicion by the transgender community, in part because they have been used by conservative media to further misleading narratives. Alex Barasch, writing in ''[[Slate (magazine)|Slate]]'', faulted the article for not including the story of "a single happy, well-adjusted trans teen" in its first 9,000 words.<ref name="slate-atlantic" /> However, one of the reader response letters published by ''The Atlantic'' identified in the article two stories of happily transitioned teens, though the author referred to them as being "buried deep in the article".<ref name="atlantic-parents" /> Barasch also criticized Singal for failing to include the stories of individuals who had detransitioned for reasons other than a realization that they were not trans, such as social stigma.<ref name="slate-atlantic" /> Some transgender advocates questioned whether it was appropriate for a [[cisgender]] man like Singal, rather than a transgender writer, to write on the topic.<ref name="economist-trans"/>


''The Atlantic'' also published a series of responses to Singal's article. One was a personal story of de-transition after being physically assaulted and transitioning again when it was safer to do so.<ref>{{Cite news |work=The Atlantic |url= https://www.theatlantic.com/family/archive/2018/06/i-detransitioned-but-not-because-i-wasnt-trans/563396/ |title=I Detransitioned. But Not Because I Wasn't Trans. |date=June 22, 2018}}</ref> Another focused on the fact that detransitioners make up a relatively small subset of those who access transition related care.<ref>{{Cite news |url= https://www.theatlantic.com/family/archive/2018/07/desistance/564560/ |work=The Atlantic |title= The Loaded Language Shaping the Trans Conversation |date=July 10, 2018}}</ref>
''The Atlantic'' also published a series of responses to Singal's article. One was a personal story of de-transition after being physically assaulted and transitioning again when it was safer to do so.<ref>{{Cite news |work=The Atlantic |url= https://www.theatlantic.com/family/archive/2018/06/i-detransitioned-but-not-because-i-wasnt-trans/563396/ |title=I Detransitioned. But Not Because I Wasn't Trans. |date=June 22, 2018}}</ref> Another focused on the fact that detransitioners make up a relatively small subset of those who access transition related care.<ref>{{Cite news |url= https://www.theatlantic.com/family/archive/2018/07/desistance/564560/ |work=The Atlantic |title= The Loaded Language Shaping the Trans Conversation |date=July 10, 2018}}</ref>


===Subsequent controversies===
===Subsequent events===
In March 2021, Singal was listed on [[GLAAD]]'s "Accountability Project", which the organization described as serving to document "[[Anti-LGBT rhetoric|anti-LGBTQ]] words and actions from politicians, commentators, organization leaders, journalists and other public figures".<ref name="advocate-accountability"/> Singal responded on [[Substack]], stating that his inclusion on the list was based on "previously disproven internet scuttlebutt". Singal was supported by sex columnist [[Dan Savage]], who derided what he described as a "long & dishonest campaign" against Singal,<ref name="hill-accountability"/> and urged readers to listen to Singal's interview of a youth-gender clinician, Dr. Erica Anderson, before judging him as transphobic.<ref name="advocate-accountability"/>
In March 2021, Singal was listed on [[GLAAD]]'s "Accountability Project", which the organization described as serving to document "[[Anti-LGBT rhetoric|anti-LGBTQ]] words and actions from politicians, commentators, organization leaders, journalists and other public figures".<ref name="advocate-accountability"/> Among other things, GLAAD criticizes Singal for misinterpreting a study on desistance among transgender children and for promoting unsupported hypotheses that sexual trauma can cause gender dysphoria and that gender dysphoria can spread via [[social contagion]].<ref name="GLAAD-accountability"/> Singal responded on [[Substack]], stating that his inclusion on the list was based on "previously disproven internet scuttlebutt".<ref name="hill-accountability"/>


==Podcast==
==Podcast==
<!-- Deleted image removed: [[File:Blocked and Reported.png|thumb|The podcast cover art{{deletable file-caption|Thursday, 24 August 2023|PROD}}]] -->
<!-- Deleted image removed: [[File:Blocked and Reported.png|thumb|The podcast cover art{{deletable file-caption|Thursday, 24 August 2023|PROD}}]] -->
Since March 2020,<ref name="tribune-pod"/> Singal has hosted the podcast ''Blocked and Reported'' with Katie Herzog, a journalist based in Washington state. The podcast's content focuses on internet culture war controversies. According to its website, "Journalists Katie Herzog and Jesse Singal scour the internet for its craziest, silliest, most sociopathic content, part of an obsessive and ill-conceived attempt to extract kernels of meaning and humanity from a landscape of endless raging dumpster fires. (And sometimes they talk about other stuff, too.)"<ref name="barpod-about">{{cite web |title=Blocked and Reported About Page |url=https://www.blockedandreported.org/about |website=Blocked and Reported on Substack |access-date=12 January 2022}}</ref> Herzog and Singal have both been described as politically liberal,<ref name="tribune-pod"/> "heterodox"<ref name="reason-pod"/> and "[[woke]]-skeptic."<ref>{{cite magazine|title=July podcast picks: online rage, taboos and obesity |magazine=[[The Week]] |date=July 23, 2021 |url=https://www.theweek.co.uk/arts-life/culture/music/953595/podcasts-of-the-week-online-rage-taboos-and-obesity |language=en}}</ref> Herzog was also the subject of online ostracism (characterized in ''The New York Times'' as an attempted [[cancel culture|cancellation]]) as a result of a controversial 2017 article she wrote for Seattle weekly ''[[The Stranger (newspaper)|The Stranger]]'' about people who have undergone [[detransition]].<ref name="nyt-cancel"/>
Since March 2020,<ref name="tribune-pod"/> Singal has hosted the podcast ''Blocked and Reported'' with Katie Herzog, a journalist based in Washington state. The podcast's content focuses on internet culture war controversies. According to its website, "Katie Herzog and Jesse Singal scour the internet for its craziest, silliest, most sociopathic content, part of an obsessive and ill-conceived attempt to extract kernels of meaning and humanity from a landscape of endless raging dumpster fires. (And sometimes they talk about other stuff, too.)"<ref name="barpod-about">{{cite web |title=Blocked and Reported About Page |url=https://www.blockedandreported.org/about |website=Blocked and Reported on Substack |access-date=12 January 2022}}</ref> Herzog and Singal have both been described as politically liberal,<ref name="tribune-pod"/> "heterodox"<ref name="reason-pod"/> and "[[woke]]-skeptic."<ref>{{cite magazine|title=July podcast picks: online rage, taboos and obesity |magazine=[[The Week]] |date=July 23, 2021 |url=https://www.theweek.co.uk/arts-life/culture/music/953595/podcasts-of-the-week-online-rage-taboos-and-obesity |language=en}}</ref> Herzog was also the subject of online ostracism (characterized in ''The New York Times'' as an attempted [[cancel culture|cancellation]]) as a result of a controversial 2017 article she wrote for Seattle weekly ''[[The Stranger (newspaper)|The Stranger]]'' about people who have undergone [[detransition]].<ref name="nyt-cancel"/>


Within three months of the podcast's debut, it had more than 1,400 financial supporters through [[Patreon]], collectively paying more than $8,000 per month.<ref name="reason-pod"/> As of July 2021, this had increased to approximately 5,600 patrons and $37,000 per month.<ref name="bnr-patreon"/> In October 2021, the podcast's website hosting and patronage services were migrated to [[Substack]], where it has over 43,000 subscribers as of November 2023.<ref>{{Cite web |last=Singal |first=Jesse |title=Blocked and Reported {{!}} Substack |url=https://www.blockedandreported.org/ |access-date=2023-11-15 |website=www.blockedandreported.org |language=en}}</ref><ref name="barpod-substack">{{cite web |title=Why Blocked And Reported Moved To Substack
Within three months of the podcast's debut, it had more than 1,400 financial supporters through [[Patreon]], collectively paying more than $8,000 per month.<ref name="reason-pod"/> As of July 2021, this had increased to approximately 5,600 patrons and $37,000 per month.<ref name="bnr-patreon"/> In October 2021, the podcast's website hosting and patronage services were migrated to [[Substack]], where it has over 46,000 subscribers as of February 2024.<ref>{{Cite web |last=Singal |first=Jesse |title=Blocked and Reported {{!}} Substack |url=https://www.blockedandreported.org/ |access-date=2023-11-15 |website=www.blockedandreported.org |language=en}}</ref><ref name="barpod-substack">{{cite web |title=Why Blocked And Reported Moved To Substack
|url=https://www.blockedandreported.org/p/why-blocked-and-reported-moved-to |website=Blocked and Reported on Substack |access-date=12 January 2022}}</ref>
|url=https://www.blockedandreported.org/p/why-blocked-and-reported-moved-to |website=Blocked and Reported on Substack |access-date=12 January 2022}}</ref>


==Book==
==Book==
Singal's debut book, ''The Quick Fix: Why Fad Psychology Can’t Cure Our Social Ills'', was published in April 2021. The book examines a number of popular psychology [[fad]]s such as [[positive psychology]], [[power posing]], and the [[implicit-association test]] which, according to Singal, turned out to have weak empirical support or reproducibility, or which were exaggerated into stronger claims which are "scientifically questionable but sexy and exciting". The book examines the [[replication crisis]] in social sciences, and some of the underlying causes such as [[p-hacking|''p''-hacking]], and suggests remedies for "how both individuals and institutions can do a better job of resisting" exaggerated pop psychology.<ref name="quick-fix"/>
Singal's first book, ''The Quick Fix: Why Fad Psychology Can't Cure Our Social Ills'', was published in April 2021. It examines a number of popular psychology [[fad]]s, such as [[positive psychology]], [[power posing]], and the [[implicit-association test]] which, according to Singal, turned out to have weak empirical support or reproducibility, or which were exaggerated into stronger claims that are "scientifically questionable but sexy and exciting". The book examines the [[replication crisis]] in social sciences and some of its underlying causes, such as [[p-hacking|''p''-hacking]], and suggests remedies for "how both individuals and institutions can do a better job of resisting" exaggerated pop psychology.<ref name="quick-fix"/>


Writing for ''[[National Review]]'', Michael M. Rosen called the book "engaging and persuasive", and wrote that it was based on "rigorous research and thoughtful interviews".<ref name="quick-fix-national-review"/> An anonymous review in ''[[Publishers Weekly]]'' called the book "impassioned yet disappointing", complaining that its presentation of scientific details was too convoluted for lay readers.<ref name="pub-weekly"/>
Writing for ''[[National Review]]'', Michael M. Rosen called the book "engaging and persuasive" and said that it was based on "rigorous research and thoughtful interviews".<ref name="quick-fix-national-review"/> An anonymous review in ''[[Publishers Weekly]]'' called the book "impassioned yet disappointing", complaining that its presentation of scientific details was too convoluted for lay readers.<ref name="pub-weekly"/>


==References==
==References==
Line 61: Line 60:
<ref name="substack-about">{{cite web|url=https://jessesingal.substack.com/about|last=Singal|first=Jesse|title=About|work=Singal-Minded}}</ref>
<ref name="substack-about">{{cite web|url=https://jessesingal.substack.com/about|last=Singal|first=Jesse|title=About|work=Singal-Minded}}</ref>
<ref name="advocate-accountability">{{cite web|url=https://www.advocate.com/commentary/2021/3/24/cis-men-jesse-singal-dan-savage-dont-decide-whats-transphobic|title=Cis Men Like Jesse Singal, Dan Savage Don't Decide What's Transphobic|last=Rude|first=Mey|date=March 24, 2021|work=The Advocate}}</ref>
<ref name="advocate-accountability">{{cite web|url=https://www.advocate.com/commentary/2021/3/24/cis-men-jesse-singal-dan-savage-dont-decide-whats-transphobic|title=Cis Men Like Jesse Singal, Dan Savage Don't Decide What's Transphobic|last=Rude|first=Mey|date=March 24, 2021|work=The Advocate}}</ref>
<ref name="GLAAD-accountability">{{cite web|url=https://glaad.org/gap/jesse-singal/|work=GLAAD Accountability Project|date=April 21, 2023|title=Jesse Singal}}</ref>
<ref name="CJR Fact-checking">{{cite web|url=https://www.cjr.org/analysis/journalism-book-fact-checking-jill-abramson.php|title= The perils of publishing without a fact-checking net |last=Neason |first= Alexandria|date=January 25, 2019|work=Columbia Journalism Review}}</ref>
<ref name="CJR Fact-checking">{{cite web|url=https://www.cjr.org/analysis/journalism-book-fact-checking-jill-abramson.php|title= The perils of publishing without a fact-checking net |last=Neason |first= Alexandria|date=January 25, 2019|work=Columbia Journalism Review}}</ref>
<ref name="hill-accountability">{{cite web|url=https://thehill.com/changing-america/respect/equality/546518-backlash-from-glaads-new-accountability-project-is-proof|work=The Hill|date=April 5, 2021|title=Backlash from GLAAD's new accountability project is proof it's working, says LGBTQ+ watchdog|last=Srikanth|first=Anagha}}</ref>
<ref name="hill-accountability">{{cite web|url=https://thehill.com/changing-america/respect/equality/546518-backlash-from-glaads-new-accountability-project-is-proof|work=The Hill|date=April 5, 2021|title=Backlash from GLAAD's new accountability project is proof it's working, says LGBTQ+ watchdog|last=Srikanth|first=Anagha}}</ref>
Line 72: Line 72:
<ref name="atlantic-parents">{{cite web|first1=Matt|last1=Peterson|first2=Caroline|last2=Kitchner|url=https://www.theatlantic.com/membership/archive/2018/06/what-do-the-parents-of-trans-kids-have-to-say/563507/|title=What Do the Parents of Trans Kids Have to Say?|work=The Atlantic|date=June 22, 2018}}</ref>
<ref name="atlantic-parents">{{cite web|first1=Matt|last1=Peterson|first2=Caroline|last2=Kitchner|url=https://www.theatlantic.com/membership/archive/2018/06/what-do-the-parents-of-trans-kids-have-to-say/563507/|title=What Do the Parents of Trans Kids Have to Say?|work=The Atlantic|date=June 22, 2018}}</ref>
<ref name="jezebel-groupthink">{{cite web|url=https://jezebel.com/private-messages-reveal-the-cis-journalist-groupthink-b-1827041764|title=Private Messages Reveal the Cis Journalist Groupthink Behind Trans Media Narratives|last=Walker|first=Harron|date=June 27, 2018|work=Jezebel}}</ref>
<ref name="jezebel-groupthink">{{cite web|url=https://jezebel.com/private-messages-reveal-the-cis-journalist-groupthink-b-1827041764|title=Private Messages Reveal the Cis Journalist Groupthink Behind Trans Media Narratives|last=Walker|first=Harron|date=June 27, 2018|work=Jezebel}}</ref>
<ref name="advocate-atlantic">{{cite web|url=https://www.advocate.com/commentary/2018/6/25/why-trans-community-hates-atlantics-cover-story|title=Why the Trans Community Hates The Atlantic's Cover Story|work=The Advocate|last=Kerri|first=Amanda|date=June 25, 2018}}</ref>
<!-- <ref name="advocate-atlantic">{{cite web|url=https://www.advocate.com/commentary/2018/6/25/why-trans-community-hates-atlantics-cover-story|title=Why the Trans Community Hates The Atlantic's Cover Story|work=The Advocate|last=Kerri|first=Amanda|date=June 25, 2018}}</ref>-->
<ref name="economist-trans">{{cite news|url=https://www.economist.com/open-future/2018/07/06/i-am-neither-trans-nor-a-woman-can-i-write-about-the-issues-they-face|newspaper=The Economist|title=I am neither trans nor a woman. Can I write about the issues they face?|last=Kirkup|first=James|date=July 6, 2018|quote=Many transgender people and their advocates argued that on such a subject the voices of transgender people should be heard first, and perhaps exclusively.}}</ref>
<ref name="economist-trans">{{cite news|url=https://www.economist.com/open-future/2018/07/06/i-am-neither-trans-nor-a-woman-can-i-write-about-the-issues-they-face|newspaper=The Economist|title=I am neither trans nor a woman. Can I write about the issues they face?|last=Kirkup|first=James|date=July 6, 2018|quote=Many transgender people and their advocates argued that on such a subject the voices of transgender people should be heard first, and perhaps exclusively.}}</ref>
<ref name="pub-weekly">{{cite web|url=https://www.publishersweekly.com/978-0-374-23980-0|work=Publishers Weekly|title=[Review] The Quick Fix: Why Fad Psychology Can't Cure Our Social Ills}}</ref>
<ref name="pub-weekly">{{cite web|url=https://www.publishersweekly.com/978-0-374-23980-0|work=Publishers Weekly|title=[Review] The Quick Fix: Why Fad Psychology Can't Cure Our Social Ills}}</ref>
Line 78: Line 78:


==External links==
==External links==
*{{Official website|https://www.jessesingal.com/}}
* {{Official website|https://www.jessesingal.com/}}
* [https://jessesingal.substack.com Singal-Minded]
* [https://blockedandreported.org ''Blocked and Reported'']


{{authority control}}
{{authority control}}
Line 94: Line 96:
[[Category:Jewish American journalists]]
[[Category:Jewish American journalists]]
[[Category:Journalists from Brooklyn]]
[[Category:Journalists from Brooklyn]]
[[Category:LGBT-related controversies in the United States]]
[[Category:21st-century American Jews]]
[[Category:Detransition]]
[[Category:Substack writers]]

Latest revision as of 10:16, 16 October 2024

Jesse Singal
Singal speaks on a Rebel Wisdom video in 2021
EducationPrinceton University (MA)
OccupationJournalist

Jesse Singal is an American journalist. He has written for publications including New York magazine, The New York Times and The Atlantic. Singal also publishes a newsletter on Substack and hosts a podcast, Blocked and Reported, with journalist Katie Herzog.

Much of Singal's writing deals with the social sciences, and he previously edited New York magazine's behavioral-science vertical, "Science of Us".[1] In 2021, he published a book, The Quick Fix, about the failings of popular psychology. Singal's writing on transgender issues has attracted controversy, particularly in his 2018 cover story for The Atlantic, "When Children Say They're Trans".

Singal's political orientation has often been described as liberal but "heterodox", though he has expressed an aversion to the latter term as a descriptor of his work.[2]

Biography

[edit]

Singal is one of three sons born to Sydney L. (née Altman; 1949–2021) and Bruce A. Singal.[3] Both of his parents were attorneys. He received a master's degree in public affairs from Princeton's Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs.[1] He is of Jewish descent[4] and lives in Brooklyn.[5]

Writing about transgender issues

[edit]

Singal has been described as one of the most prominent journalists working in the area of transgender issues,[6][7] though he has also been criticized as writing with an anti-transgender bias.[8]

2018 Atlantic article

[edit]

Singal wrote the cover story for the July/August 2018 issue of The Atlantic. Originally published under the title "When a Child Says She's Trans", the online version was later retitled "When Children Say They're Trans". The long-form piece includes profiles of several adolescents who identify or previously identified as transgender, interviews with youth gender clinicians, and reviews of some of the studies, statistics, and protocols related to youth transition. In a follow-up, The Atlantic published four letters from parents of transgender children reacting to Singal's article with a mixture of criticism and praise.[9] Alexandria Neason, writing for the Columbia Journalism Review, stated that despite being fact-checked, the story was considered transphobic by many readers, journalists and activists, and suggested that more diversity in editorial oversight could have averted the problem.[10]

Among the controversial aspects of the article was the proportion of weight given to stories of adolescents who had desisted or detransitioned—that is, reverted to identifying with their genders assigned at birth, either before or after undergoing physical transition. In the article, Singal acknowledges that the stories of detransitioners are sometimes viewed with skepticism or suspicion by the transgender community, in part because they have been used by conservative media to further misleading narratives. Alex Barasch, writing in Slate, faulted the article for not including the story of "a single happy, well-adjusted trans teen" in its first 9,000 words.[11] However, one of the reader response letters published by The Atlantic identified in the article two stories of happily transitioned teens, though the author referred to them as being "buried deep in the article".[9] Barasch also criticized Singal for failing to include the stories of individuals who had detransitioned for reasons other than a realization that they were not trans, such as social stigma.[11] Some transgender advocates questioned whether it was appropriate for a cisgender man like Singal, rather than a transgender writer, to write on the topic.[12]

The Atlantic also published a series of responses to Singal's article. One was a personal story of de-transition after being physically assaulted and transitioning again when it was safer to do so.[13] Another focused on the fact that detransitioners make up a relatively small subset of those who access transition related care.[14]

Subsequent events

[edit]

In March 2021, Singal was listed on GLAAD's "Accountability Project", which the organization described as serving to document "anti-LGBTQ words and actions from politicians, commentators, organization leaders, journalists and other public figures".[6] Among other things, GLAAD criticizes Singal for misinterpreting a study on desistance among transgender children and for promoting unsupported hypotheses that sexual trauma can cause gender dysphoria and that gender dysphoria can spread via social contagion.[8] Singal responded on Substack, stating that his inclusion on the list was based on "previously disproven internet scuttlebutt".[15]

Podcast

[edit]

Since March 2020,[16] Singal has hosted the podcast Blocked and Reported with Katie Herzog, a journalist based in Washington state. The podcast's content focuses on internet culture war controversies. According to its website, "Katie Herzog and Jesse Singal scour the internet for its craziest, silliest, most sociopathic content, part of an obsessive and ill-conceived attempt to extract kernels of meaning and humanity from a landscape of endless raging dumpster fires. (And sometimes they talk about other stuff, too.)"[17] Herzog and Singal have both been described as politically liberal,[16] "heterodox"[18] and "woke-skeptic."[19] Herzog was also the subject of online ostracism (characterized in The New York Times as an attempted cancellation) as a result of a controversial 2017 article she wrote for Seattle weekly The Stranger about people who have undergone detransition.[20]

Within three months of the podcast's debut, it had more than 1,400 financial supporters through Patreon, collectively paying more than $8,000 per month.[18] As of July 2021, this had increased to approximately 5,600 patrons and $37,000 per month.[21] In October 2021, the podcast's website hosting and patronage services were migrated to Substack, where it has over 46,000 subscribers as of February 2024.[22][23]

Book

[edit]

Singal's first book, The Quick Fix: Why Fad Psychology Can't Cure Our Social Ills, was published in April 2021. It examines a number of popular psychology fads, such as positive psychology, power posing, and the implicit-association test which, according to Singal, turned out to have weak empirical support or reproducibility, or which were exaggerated into stronger claims that are "scientifically questionable but sexy and exciting". The book examines the replication crisis in social sciences and some of its underlying causes, such as p-hacking, and suggests remedies for "how both individuals and institutions can do a better job of resisting" exaggerated pop psychology.[24]

Writing for National Review, Michael M. Rosen called the book "engaging and persuasive" and said that it was based on "rigorous research and thoughtful interviews".[2] An anonymous review in Publishers Weekly called the book "impassioned yet disappointing", complaining that its presentation of scientific details was too convoluted for lay readers.[25]

References

[edit]
  1. ^ a b Singal, Jesse. "About Me". jessesingal.com.
  2. ^ a b Rosen, Michael M. (1 July 2021). "How Flawed Social Science Leads Us Astray". National Review.
  3. ^ "Sydney L. Altman". The Boston Globe. 22 April 2021 – via Newspapers.com.
  4. ^ Jonathan, Chait; Singal, Jesse (16 November 2016). "How Alarmed Should American Jews Be Right Now? Two Jews Kibitz". New York Magazine. Two of New York Magazine's Jewish staffers, Jonathan Chait and Jesse Singal, decided to discuss the question.
  5. ^ Singal, Jesse. "About". Singal-Minded.
  6. ^ a b Rude, Mey (24 March 2021). "Cis Men Like Jesse Singal, Dan Savage Don't Decide What's Transphobic". The Advocate.
  7. ^ Walker, Harron (27 June 2018). "Private Messages Reveal the Cis Journalist Groupthink Behind Trans Media Narratives". Jezebel.
  8. ^ a b "Jesse Singal". GLAAD Accountability Project. 21 April 2023.
  9. ^ a b Peterson, Matt; Kitchner, Caroline (22 June 2018). "What Do the Parents of Trans Kids Have to Say?". The Atlantic.
  10. ^ Neason, Alexandria (25 January 2019). "The perils of publishing without a fact-checking net". Columbia Journalism Review.
  11. ^ a b Barasch, Alex (20 June 2018). "Sacred Bodies". Slate.
  12. ^ Kirkup, James (6 July 2018). "I am neither trans nor a woman. Can I write about the issues they face?". The Economist. Many transgender people and their advocates argued that on such a subject the voices of transgender people should be heard first, and perhaps exclusively.
  13. ^ "I Detransitioned. But Not Because I Wasn't Trans". The Atlantic. 22 June 2018.
  14. ^ "The Loaded Language Shaping the Trans Conversation". The Atlantic. 10 July 2018.
  15. ^ Srikanth, Anagha (5 April 2021). "Backlash from GLAAD's new accountability project is proof it's working, says LGBTQ+ watchdog". The Hill.
  16. ^ a b Zorn, Eric (21 May 2021). "Two more for the road: My new favorite podcasts". Chicago Tribune.
  17. ^ "Blocked and Reported About Page". Blocked and Reported on Substack. Retrieved 12 January 2022.
  18. ^ a b Gillespie, Nick (17 June 2020). "Katie Herzog and Jesse Singal on Left-Wing Cancel Culture". Reason.
  19. ^ "July podcast picks: online rage, taboos and obesity". The Week. 23 July 2021.
  20. ^ McDermott, John (2 November 2019). "Those People We Tried to Cancel? They're All Hanging Out Together". The New York Times.
  21. ^ "Blocked and Reported". Patreon.
  22. ^ Singal, Jesse. "Blocked and Reported | Substack". www.blockedandreported.org. Retrieved 15 November 2023.
  23. ^ "Why Blocked And Reported Moved To Substack". Blocked and Reported on Substack. Retrieved 12 January 2022.
  24. ^ Singal, Jesse. The Quick Fix: Why Fad Psychology Can't Cure Our Social Ills.
  25. ^ "[Review] The Quick Fix: Why Fad Psychology Can't Cure Our Social Ills". Publishers Weekly.
[edit]
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Jesse_Singal&oldid=1251478128"