Big Dumb Object: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added

Inline

Latest revision as of 11:01, 28 October 2024

In discussion of science fiction, a Big Dumb Object (BDO) is any mysterious object, usually of extraterrestrial or unknown origin and immense power, in a story which generates an intense sense of wonder by its mere existence. To a certain extent, the term deliberately deflates the intended grandeur of the mysterious object.

The coining of the term has been attributed to reviewer Roz Kaveney in 1981,^[1] but it was not in general use until Peter Nicholls included it in The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction as a joke in 1993.^[2]

Edward Guimont and Horace A. Smith propose that the origins of the Big Dumb Object trope can be found in H. P. Lovecraft's novellas At the Mountains of Madness and The Shadow Out of Time, both of which feature human expeditions to immense ancient alien cities in remote parts of our world, and both of which were early influences upon Arthur C. Clarke.^[3]

Big Dumb Objects often exhibit extreme or unusual properties, or a total absence of some expected properties:^[4]

The monolith in Stanley Kubrick and Arthur C. Clarke's 2001: A Space Odyssey (foreshadowed in The Sentinel) is an indecipherable influence upon the protohumans who it first appears to. Later in the film, the monolith serves to show how little humans have evolved. The astronaut Bowman's attempt to interact with the monolith only makes him a part of its mystery.^[5]

In Arthur C. Clarke's novel Rendezvous with Rama, a 50km-long cylinder is detected entering the solar system. A similar cylindrical probe of gargantuan dimensions threatens Earth in Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home.
The object discovered in Quatermass and the Pit was made of a material of extreme hardness, such that diamond-tipped drills and acetylene torches would not damage it. At the same time nothing would adhere to it.

Charles Sheffield's Heritage Universe setting features many immense alien artifacts, some of which are more inscrutable than others.

The Marker from Dead Space emits a persistent electromagnetic field from seemingly no source, which could be used to provide limitless energy. Attempting to reverse engineer the Marker, scientists discover that the electromagnetic fields generated by the Marker cause living people to suffer paranoia and hallucinations, while also causing the dead to reanimate, becoming "Necromorphs".

In the movie based on Michael Crichton's novel Sphere, the eponymous object would reflect everything in its presence except people. If it did reflect someone, she or he was alone, and the individual was accepted as worthy to harness the device's power.

In Iain Banks' novel Against a Dark Background, the Lazy Guns have a lot of mass and yet little weight, and weigh three times as much upside-down as upright.
- By the same author, the titular Excession is a blackbody sphere that appears on the edge of Culture space and just sits there being inscrutable (even to Culture technology).

The dome from the Stephen King novel and television show Under the Dome is large and transparent unless touched by a person; it gives a slight electric shock when touched for the first time by someone, but not afterward. It cannot be penetrated, even by a MOAB bomb, and is seemingly causing many mysterious events in Chester's Mill, the town that the dome is enclosing, including causing all electronic devices near it to explode, visions, and, in one character, premature birth.

In Dan Simmons' 1989 novel Hyperion, the mysterious Time Tombs, "huge brooding structures" which are moving backwards through time, and whose purpose, origin, and nature are not explained in the book, are the objective of the characters' pilgrimage.

Such unexpected properties are usually used to rule out conventional origins for the BDO and increase the sense of mystery, and even fear, for the characters interacting with it.

References

^ Kaveney, Roz, 1981, Foundation: The International Review of Science Fiction, issue 22.
^ Nicholls, Peter, 2000, Big Dumb Objects and Cosmic Enigmas: The Love Affair between Space Fiction and the Transcendental, in Westfahl, Gary (ed), Space and Beyond: The Frontier Theme in Science Fiction, Greenwood Press, p. 13. "... I decided to write an April Fool's entry. I would pretend that a phrase I’d always liked, originated by the critic Roz Kaveney but not in general use, was actually a known critical term. I would write an entry called 'Big Dumb Objects' in a poker-faced style, suggesting an even more absurd critical term to be used in its place, 'megalotropic sf.'"
^ Guimont, Edward; Smith, Horace A. (2023). When the Stars Are Right: H. P. Lovecraft and Astronomy (First ed.). New York City: Hippocampus Press. pp. 305–07. ISBN 9781614984078.
^ Palmer, Christopher (2006). "Big Dumb Objects in Science Fiction: Sublimity, Banality, and Modernity". Extrapolation. 47 (1): 95–111. doi:10.3828/extr.2006.47.1.10. ISSN 0014-5483.
^ https://www.collativelearning.com/2001%20chapter%^{[dead link]}

External links

Big Dumb Objects at The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction, 3rd edition

[1] Kaveney, Roz, 1981, Foundation: The International Review of Science Fiction, issue 22.

[2] Nicholls, Peter, 2000, Big Dumb Objects and Cosmic Enigmas: The Love Affair between Space Fiction and the Transcendental, in Westfahl, Gary (ed), Space and Beyond: The Frontier Theme in Science Fiction, Greenwood Press, p. 13. "... I decided to write an April Fool's entry. I would pretend that a phrase I’d always liked, originated by the critic Roz Kaveney but not in general use, was actually a known critical term. I would write an entry called 'Big Dumb Objects' in a poker-faced style, suggesting an even more absurd critical term to be used in its place, 'megalotropic sf.'"

[When-3] Guimont, Edward; Smith, Horace A. (2023). When the Stars Are Right: H. P. Lovecraft and Astronomy (First ed.). New York City: Hippocampus Press. pp. 305–07. ISBN 9781614984078.

[4] Palmer, Christopher (2006). "Big Dumb Objects in Science Fiction: Sublimity, Banality, and Modernity". Extrapolation. 47 (1): 95–111. doi:10.3828/extr.2006.47.1.10. ISSN 0014-5483.

[5] ttps://www.collativelearning.com/2001%20chapter%^{[dead link]}

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
 {{Short description|Plot device}}
-In discussion of [[science fiction]], a '''Big Dumb Object''' ('''BDO''') is any mysterious object, usually of [[extraterrestrial life|extraterrestrial]] or unknown origin and immense power, in a story which generates an intense [[sense of wonder]] by its mere existence. To a certain buextent, the term deliberately deflates this.
+In discussion of [[science fiction]], a '''Big Dumb Object''' ('''BDO''') is any mysterious object, usually of [[extraterrestrial life|extraterrestrial]] or unknown origin and immense power, in a story which generates an intense [[sense of wonder]] by its mere existence. To a certain extent, the term deliberately deflates the intended grandeur of the mysterious object.
-The term was not in general use until [[Peter Nicholls (writer)|Peter Nicholls]] included it in ''[[The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction]]'' as a joke in 1993,<ref>Nicholls, Peter, 2000, ''Big Dumb Objects and Cosmic Enigmas: The Love Affair between Space Fiction and the Transcendental'', in Westfahl, Gary (ed), ''Space and Beyond: The Frontier Theme in Science Fiction'', Greenwood Press, p. 13. "... I decided to write an April Fool's entry. I would pretend that a phrase I’d always liked, originated by the critic Roz Kaveney but not in general use, was actually a known critical term. I would write an entry called 'Big Dumb Objects' in a poker-faced style, suggesting an even more absurd critical term to be used in its place, 'megalotropic sf.'"</ref> while its creation has been attributed to reviewer [[Roz Kaveney]].<ref>Kaveney, Roz, 1981, ''[[Foundation - The International Review of Science Fiction|Foundation: The International Review of Science Fiction]]'', issue 22.</ref>
+The coining of the term has been attributed to reviewer [[Roz Kaveney]] in 1981,<ref>Kaveney, Roz, 1981, ''[[Foundation - The International Review of Science Fiction|Foundation: The International Review of Science Fiction]]'', issue 22.</ref> but it was not in general use until [[Peter Nicholls (writer)|Peter Nicholls]] included it in ''[[The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction]]'' as a joke in 1993.<ref>Nicholls, Peter, 2000, ''Big Dumb Objects and Cosmic Enigmas: The Love Affair between Space Fiction and the Transcendental'', in Westfahl, Gary (ed), ''Space and Beyond: The Frontier Theme in Science Fiction'', Greenwood Press, p. 13. "... I decided to write an April Fool's entry. I would pretend that a phrase I’d always liked, originated by the critic Roz Kaveney but not in general use, was actually a known critical term. I would write an entry called 'Big Dumb Objects' in a poker-faced style, suggesting an even more absurd critical term to be used in its place, 'megalotropic sf.'"</ref>
+Edward Guimont and Horace A. Smith propose that the origins of the Big Dumb Object trope can be found in [[H. P. Lovecraft]]'s novellas ''[[At the Mountains of Madness]]'' and ''[[The Shadow Out of Time]]'', both of which feature human expeditions to immense ancient alien cities in remote parts of our world, and both of which were early influences upon [[Arthur C. Clarke]].<ref name="When">{{Cite book|last1 = Guimont|first1 = Edward|url = https://www.hippocampuspress.com/other-authors/nonfiction/when-the-stars-are-right-h.-p.-lovecraft-and-astronomy|title = When the Stars Are Right: H. P. Lovecraft and Astronomy|last2 = Smith|first2 = Horace A.|year = 2023|publisher = [[Hippocampus Press]]|isbn = 9781614984078|edition = First|location = [[New York City]]|pages = 305–07}}</ref>
 Big Dumb Objects often exhibit extreme or unusual properties, or a total absence of some expected properties:<ref>{{Cite journal|last=Palmer|first=Christopher|date=2006|title=Big Dumb Objects in Science Fiction: Sublimity, Banality, and Modernity|url=https://online.liverpooluniversitypress.co.uk/doi/abs/10.3828/extr.2006.47.1.10?journalCode=extr|journal=Extrapolation|language=en|volume=47|issue=1|pages=95–111|doi=10.3828/extr.2006.47.1.10|issn=0014-5483}}</ref>
-*The monolith in Stanley Kubrick and [[Arthur C. Clarke]]'s ''[[2001: A Space Odyssey]]'' (foreshadowed in ''[[The Sentinel (short story)|The Sentinel]]'') is an indecipherable influence on the protohumans to whom it first appears, and later in the film serves to show how little humans have evolved.  Astronaut Bowman's attempt to interact with the monolith only makes him a part of its mystery.
+* The monolith in Stanley Kubrick and [[Arthur C. Clarke]]'s ''[[2001: A Space Odyssey]]'' (foreshadowed in ''[[The Sentinel (short story) |The Sentinel]]'') is an indecipherable influence upon the protohumans who it first appears to. Later in the film, the monolith serves to show how little humans have evolved. The astronaut Bowman's attempt to interact with the monolith only makes him a part of its mystery.<ref>https://www.collativelearning.com/2001%20chapter%<nowiki/>{{Dead url|date=July 2024}}</ref>
-*In [[Arthur C. Clarke]]'s novel ''[[Rendezvous with Rama]]'', a 50km-long cylinder is detected entering the solar system. A similar cylindrical probe of gargantuan dimensions threatens Earth in ''[[Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home]]''.
+* In [[Arthur C. Clarke]]'s novel ''[[Rendezvous with Rama]]'', a 50km-long cylinder is detected entering the solar system. A similar cylindrical probe of gargantuan dimensions threatens Earth in ''[[Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home]]''.
 *The object discovered in ''[[Quatermass and the Pit]]'' was made of a material of extreme hardness, such that [[diamond]]-tipped drills and [[acetylene]] torches would not damage it. At the same time nothing would adhere to it.
-*[[Charles Sheffield]]'s [[Heritage Universe]] setting features many immense alien artifacts, some of which are more inscrutable than others.
+* [[Charles Sheffield]]'s [[Heritage Universe]] setting features many immense alien artifacts, some of which are more inscrutable than others.
-* The Marker from [[Dead Space (series)|Dead Space]] emits a persistent electromagnetic field from seemingly no source, which could be used to provide limitless energy. Attempting to reverse engineer the Marker, scientists discover that the electromagnetic fields generated by the Marker cause living people to suffer paranoia and hallucinations, while also causing the dead to reanimate, becoming "necromorphs".
-*In the [[Sphere (1998 film)|movie]] based on [[Michael Crichton]]'s novel ''[[Sphere (novel)|Sphere]]'', the eponymous object would reflect everything in its presence except people. If it did reflect someone, she or he was alone, and the individual was accepted as worthy to harness the device's power.
+* The Marker from ''[[Dead Space (series)|Dead Space]]'' emits a persistent electromagnetic field from seemingly no source, which could be used to provide limitless energy. Attempting to reverse engineer the Marker, scientists discover that the electromagnetic fields generated by the Marker cause living people to suffer paranoia and hallucinations, while also causing the dead to reanimate, becoming "[[Necromorphs]]".
-*In [[Iain Banks]]' novel ''[[Against a Dark Background]]'', the Lazy Guns have a lot of mass and yet little weight, and weigh three times as much upside-down as upright.
-**By the same author, the titular [[Excession]] is a blackbody sphere that appears on the edge of Culture space and just sits there being inscrutable (even to Culture technology).
+* In the [[Sphere (1998 film)|movie]] based on [[Michael Crichton]]'s novel ''[[Sphere (novel)|Sphere]]'', the eponymous object would reflect everything in its presence except people. If it did reflect someone, she or he was alone, and the individual was accepted as worthy to harness the device's power.
-*The dome from the [[Stephen King]] [[Under the Dome (novel)|novel]] and [[Under the Dome (TV series)|television show]] ''Under the Dome'' is large and transparent unless touched by a person; it gives a slight electric shock when touched for the first time by someone, but not afterward. It cannot be penetrated, even by a [[MOAB]], and is seemingly causing many mysterious events in Chester's Mill, the town that the dome is enclosing, including causing all electronic devices near it to explode, visions, and, in one character, [[premature birth]].
-*In Dan Simmons' 1989 novel ''[[Hyperion (Simmons novel)|Hyperion]]'', the mysterious Time Tombs, "huge brooding structures" which are moving backwards through time, and whose purpose, origin, and nature are not explained in the book, are the objective of the characters' pilgrimage.
+* In [[Iain Banks]]' novel ''[[Against a Dark Background]]'', the Lazy Guns have a lot of mass and yet little weight, and weigh three times as much upside-down as upright.
+** By the same author, the titular [[Excession]] is a [[Black body|blackbody]] sphere that appears on the edge of Culture space and just sits there being inscrutable (even to Culture technology).
+* The dome from the [[Stephen King]] [[Under the Dome (novel)|novel]] and [[Under the Dome (TV series)|television show]] ''Under the Dome'' is large and transparent unless touched by a person; it gives a slight electric shock when touched for the first time by someone, but not afterward. It cannot be penetrated, even by a [[MOAB]] bomb, and is seemingly causing many mysterious events in Chester's Mill, the town that the dome is enclosing, including causing all electronic devices near it to explode, visions, and, in one character, [[premature birth]].
+* In Dan Simmons' 1989 novel ''[[Hyperion (Simmons novel)|Hyperion]]'', the mysterious Time Tombs, "huge brooding structures" which are moving backwards through time, and whose purpose, origin, and nature are not explained in the book, are the objective of the characters' pilgrimage.
 Such unexpected properties are usually used to rule out conventional origins for the BDO and increase the sense of mystery, and even fear, for the characters interacting with it.
 ==See also==
-*[[Megastructure]]
+* [[Dyson sphere]]
-*[[MacGuffin]]
+* [[MacGuffin]]
-*[[Dyson sphere]]
+* [[Megastructure]]
-*[[Ringworld]]
+* [[Ringworld]]
 ==References==
@@ Line 30: / Line 39: @@
 == External links ==
+* [http://sf-encyclopedia.com/entry/big_dumb_objects Big Dumb Objects] at ''[[The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction]]'', 3rd edition
+[[Category:1993 neologisms]]
-* [http://sf-encyclopedia.com/entry/big_dumb_objects Big Dumb Objects] at [[The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction]], 3rd edition
-[[Category:Science fiction themes]]
 [[Category:Fictional objects]]
 [[Category:Narratology]]
-[[Category:1993 neologisms]]
+[[Category:Science fiction themes]]