Overleg gebruiker:Gidonb
Archief
Wegens aanhoudend misbruik van mijn pagina's zijn dezen definitief buiten gebruik. Ontgrendelen gaat hierin geen verschil maken. Communicatie is in principe mogelijk via en.wiki maar dan niet over nl.wiki. Gezien de slechte kwaliteit, het eeuwige geruzie tussen deelnemers en het anarchistische karakter ben ik van mening dat de Nederlandstalige Wikipedia in het geheel negatieve waarde heeft. Opheffing zou de beste oplossing zijn. Omdat hier toch een traditie van vrijwilligerswerk is ontstaan, zou men heel eventueel Nlwiki ook kunnen beperken tot Nederlandse onderwerpen, die dan vertaald en nagekeken kunnen worden door wikipedia met kwaliteit, hierbij ook intern iets winnend aan kwaliteit door een betere verhouding van artikelen tot editors.
Enwiki legt uit waarom Nlwiki de slechtste grotere wikipedia is
Kopie van: en:Dutch Wikipedia
Quality
The depth or editing depth of Wikipedia is a rough indicator of the encyclopedia's collaborative quality, showing how frequently its articles are updated.[1] The depth is measured by taking the average number of edits per article multiplied by the extent in which articles are supported by discussion (among other things, talk pages). Among the nine language editions with one million articles, the Dutch, Swedish, and Polish Wikipedias in that order have depth parameters much lower than the other six.[2] As of March 2012, for the English version the article depth is 666, for the German 88, for the French 153, for the Spanish 160, for the Dutch only 18.[3]
Compared to most other Wikipedia editions with a similar number of articles, articles on the Dutch Wikipedia have less content with an average of 1,598 bytes per article (as of Februay, 2014). This is roughly 40% of that of the French, German, Italian, Russian, and Spanish editions (3,986–4,277 bytes/article (as of February, 2014).[4]
Culture
In 2015 an article in De Volkskrant, basing itself on an internal inquiry by the Dutch branch of the Wikimedia Foundation, reported that most of the surveyed Wikipedians described the atmosphere on the Dutch Wikipedia as confrontational and distrustful, while naming personal egos and stubbornness as main causes of conflicts.[5]
On the 4th of February 2019 NRC Handelsblad published an article about the Dutch Wikipedia named "The Great Wikipedia edit wars", in which it described that, although Dutch Wikipedia had around 1200 regular editors, most of the power-hierarchy within the Dutch Wikipedia project effectually resided with a smaller close-knit in-group of about 200 Wikipedians, consisting of moderators and hardcore editors.[6]
References
- ↑ Wikipedia article depth; Wikimedia
- ↑ List of Wikipedias. Wikimedia. Geraadpleegd op 19 January 2014.
- ↑ Find out more-Wikipedia; Utrecht University Library
- ↑ Wikimedia Statistics, Wikipedia statistics, bytes per article. Retrieved 18 February 2015
- ↑ De Volkskrant: Leve de Wikipediaan sympathieke online betweter (Dutch), published on 30 November 2015, Retrieved 7 August 2020.
- ↑ NRC Handelsblad: NRC Handelsblad De grote Wikipedia bewerkingsoorlogen (Dutch), published 4 February 2019, Retrieved 7 August 2020.
|
Vertrokken Deze gebruiker heeft de Nederlandstalige Wikipedia in 2007 verlaten. Communicatie is beperkt mogelijk via de Engelstalige Wikipedia. Berichten hieronder worden onbeantwoord verwijderd. |
