Talk:John Nutt: Revision history

13 February 2024

• curprev 08:0108:01, 13 February 2024 Qwerfjkl (bot) talk contribs 22,784 bytes −30 Implementing WP:PIQA (Task 26) undo Tag: Talk banner shell conversion

4 September 2020

• curprev 02:1302:13, 4 September 2020 Natg 19 talk contribs 22,814 bytes −17 →Requested move 5 August 2020: clarify undo
• curprev 02:1202:12, 4 September 2020 Natg 19 talk contribs 22,831 bytes +1,077 →Requested move 5 August 2020: no consensus undo

31 August 2020

• curprev 22:0722:07, 31 August 2020 Born2cycle talk contribs 21,754 bytes +319 →Requested move 5 August 2020: search works. Did not break it undo
• curprev 14:5914:59, 31 August 2020 Andrewa talk contribs 21,435 bytes +606 →Requested move 5 August 2020: no, just get organised undo Tag: 2017 wikitext editor
• curprev 05:0705:07, 31 August 2020 Roman Spinner talk contribs 20,829 bytes +2,359 →Requested move 5 August 2020: :::::::You are correct, of course, regarding a wider forum. I just felt obliged to comment here basically because of the earlier "Nom doesn't actually offer any concrete rationale for this move..." posting. Nevertheless, as to your point — "we could just as easily say 'since most Wikipedia pages are at a base name and not disambiguated, unless there is a prior consensus for a lack of primary topic undo

30 August 2020

• curprev 20:4320:43, 30 August 2020 Born2cycle talk contribs m 18,470 bytes +1,134 →Requested move 5 August 2020: It’s a beautiful thing undo
• curprev 19:1619:16, 30 August 2020 Andrewa talk contribs 17,336 bytes +633 →Requested move 5 August 2020: what the page views show undo Tag: 2017 wikitext editor
• curprev 14:5714:57, 30 August 2020 Yaksar talk contribs 16,703 bytes +1,291 r undo

29 August 2020

• curprev 06:1506:15, 29 August 2020 Roman Spinner talk contribs 15,412 bytes +1,776 →Requested move 5 August 2020: :::::Consensus regarding matters other than primary topics, or matters that cannot be easily viewed from a reverse angle, obviously need to be decided on a case-by-case basis. As far as primary topics are concerned, however, the bar for ''elevation to'' or ''retention of'' primary should be set high. The simple question should be, {{green|"would this non-uniquely-named subject be able to muster a near-unanimous consensus undo

28 August 2020

• curprev 18:4118:41, 28 August 2020 Yaksar talk contribs 13,636 bytes +1,095 →Requested move 5 August 2020: r undo
• curprev 07:5307:53, 28 August 2020 Born2cycle talk contribs 12,541 bytes +523 →Requested move 5 August 2020: o. Editors like Andrewa may disagree with our users’ search priorities, but that’s no reason to stick it to them. undo

27 August 2020

• curprev 08:5508:55, 27 August 2020 Andrewa talk contribs 12,018 bytes +596 →Requested move 5 August 2020: support undo Tag: 2017 wikitext editor

26 August 2020

• curprev 23:3723:37, 26 August 2020 Roman Spinner talk contribs 11,422 bytes +1,058 :::Of course, names such as George Washington or Albert Einstein (a family joke of Albert Brooks' comedian father, Harry Einstein [stage name Parkyakarkus], was to name his son Albert) would fall under the description of "unanimous or near-unanimous agreement that this is indeed an obvious primary topic which nobody can deny" and only a troll would waste time at RM by nominating any such name. It is all the other undo
• curprev 18:1118:11, 26 August 2020 Station1 talk contribs 10,364 bytes −4 →Requested move 5 August 2020: clarify undo
• curprev 18:1018:10, 26 August 2020 Station1 talk contribs 10,368 bytes +14 →Requested move 5 August 2020: clarify undo
• curprev 18:0318:03, 26 August 2020 Station1 talk contribs 10,354 bytes +492 →Requested move 5 August 2020: re undo
• curprev 06:1906:19, 26 August 2020 Roman Spinner talk contribs 9,862 bytes +1,292 →Requested move 5 August 2020: *'''Comment'''. Regarding "We need some concrete reason if we're to change the status quo..." a large majority of current primary topics are not primary because they were voted upon and chosen by consensus, but simply because they were created first and became primary by default. If the creator of the second or the third "John Nutt" entry, or of the John Nutt dab page, had simply added undo

24 August 2020

• curprev 19:0119:01, 24 August 2020 Crouch, Swale talk contribs 8,570 bytes +365 →Requested move 5 August 2020: weak support undo

23 August 2020

• curprev 07:4407:44, 23 August 2020 Chris.sherlock talk contribs 8,205 bytes +288 →Requested move 5 August 2020 undo
• curprev 07:4207:42, 23 August 2020 Chris.sherlock talk contribs 7,917 bytes +279 →Requested move 5 August 2020 undo

20 August 2020

• curprev 18:3918:39, 20 August 2020 Station1 talk contribs 7,638 bytes +403 →Requested move 5 August 2020: re undo
• curprev 18:2018:20, 20 August 2020 Station1 talk contribs 7,235 bytes +317 →Requested move 5 August 2020: oppose but undo
• curprev 05:3805:38, 20 August 2020 Steel1943 talk contribs 6,918 bytes +179 →Requested move 5 August 2020: relish undo

18 August 2020

• curprev 20:3820:38, 18 August 2020 Amakuru talk contribs 6,739 bytes +498 →Requested move 5 August 2020: o undo

14 August 2020

• curprev 20:5920:59, 14 August 2020 Yaksar talk contribs 6,241 bytes +288 →Requested move 5 August 2020: o undo

13 August 2020

• curprev 21:0521:05, 13 August 2020 DuncanHill talk contribs 5,953 bytes +330 →Requested move 5 August 2020: as the notes say if you bothered to read them "If a user browses to a redirect, a pageview is registered for the redirect but not for the target page". undo
• curprev 21:0221:02, 13 August 2020 Cuchullain talk contribs 5,623 bytes +445 →Requested move 5 August 2020 undo
• curprev 20:4920:49, 13 August 2020 DuncanHill talk contribs 5,178 bytes +239 →Requested move 5 August 2020: Not "over 73%", more like 61%. Please do not quote false figures. undo
• curprev 20:4120:41, 13 August 2020 Cuchullain talk contribs 4,939 bytes +237 →Requested move 5 August 2020 undo
• curprev 01:1001:10, 13 August 2020 DuncanHill talk contribs 4,702 bytes +546 →Requested move 5 August 2020: comment on pageview graphs undo
• curprev 00:5900:59, 13 August 2020 DuncanHill talk contribs 4,156 bytes +294 →Requested move 5 August 2020: Support undo
• curprev 00:5000:50, 13 August 2020 BD2412 talk contribs 3,862 bytes +248 →Requested move 5 August 2020: *'''Support'''. The pirate may be more notable than the other topic, but is still itself a topic of marginal notability. undo

12 August 2020

• curprev 12:1312:13, 12 August 2020 JHunterJ talk contribs 3,614 bytes +383 →Requested move 5 August 2020: oppose undo

7 August 2020

• curprev 04:0104:01, 7 August 2020 Dicklyon talk contribs 3,231 bytes +227 →Requested move 5 August 2020 undo

6 August 2020

• curprev 14:2514:25, 6 August 2020 Shhhnotsoloud talk contribs 3,004 bytes +671 →Requested move 5 August 2020: o undo

5 August 2020

• curprev 10:5310:53, 5 August 2020 Necrothesp talk contribs 2,333 bytes +117 →Requested move 5 August 2020 undo
• curprev 04:3004:30, 5 August 2020 Ortizesp talk contribs 2,216 bytes +109 →Requested move 5 August 2020 undo
• curprev 03:4803:48, 5 August 2020 Roman Spinner talk contribs 2,107 bytes +699 {{subst:requested move | new1 = John Nutt (pirate) | current2 = John Nutt (disambiguation) | new2 = John Nutt | reason = It does not appear that, after 400 years, this pirate's historical legacy looms so large that it completely overshadows the combined prominence of the other two same-named men and becomes the unquestioned WP:PRIMARYTOPIC undo

28 November 2017

• curprev 13:2113:21, 28 November 2017 InternetArchiveBot talk contribs 1,408 bytes +1,000 Notification of altered sources needing review #IABot (v1.6.1) undo

26 March 2014

• curprev 06:2706:27, 26 March 2014 OccultZone talk contribs m 408 bytes −2 clean up, general fixes using AWB undo

17 September 2012

• curprev 19:0119:01, 17 September 2012 Yobot talk contribs m 410 bytes +61 WPBIO banner fixes + cleanup (Task: 17) using AWB (8413) undo

24 December 2009

• curprev 07:4807:48, 24 December 2009 DYKHousekeepingBot talk contribs m 349 bytes +156 Bot updating {{dyktalk}} undo

19 July 2009

• curprev 11:5211:52, 19 July 2009 EarwigBot I talk contribs m 193 bytes +41 Bot: EarwigBot I Task 6: Adding timestamp and reviewer to undated accepted AfC submission (Type A). undo

17 June 2009

• curprev 11:3411:34, 17 June 2009 Yobot talk contribs m 152 bytes +11 Tagging(Plugin++) living=no. using AWB undo

19 April 2009

• curprev 12:5812:58, 19 April 2009 ListasBot talk contribs 141 bytes +14 Applied fixes to WPBiography template. Did I get it wrong? undo

5 March 2009

• curprev 14:5514:55, 5 March 2009 Xenobot talk contribs m 127 bytes +3 Bot) Updating transclusions for WikiProject Piracy banner (report errors? undo

20 June 2008

• curprev 16:3116:31, 20 June 2008 Gatoclass talk contribs 124 bytes +25 DYK undo

13 June 2008

• curprev 23:3323:33, 13 June 2008 71.184.47.179 talk 99 bytes +99 ←Created page with '{{WPAFC|class=start}} {{WPBiography|class=Start|listas=Nutt, John}} {{WP-Piracybanner|class=start}}'