Nicholas Rutherford in Drunk History (2013)

Nicholas Rutherford, Beck Bennett, and Kyle Mooney in Let's Talk About Something More Interesting (2011)

Nicholas Rutherford, Milana Vayntrub, Beck Bennett, Kyle Mooney, and Stevie Nelson in Let's Talk About Something More Interesting (2011)

Jon Gries, Nicholas Rutherford, Mark Proksch, Ahmed Bharoocha, and Daniel Stessen at an event for IMDb at San Diego Comic-Con 2018 (2018)

Nicholas Rutherford, Robert Schwartzman, Lucy Hale, Lauren Lapkus, Maya Kazan, and Darrell Britt-Gibson at an event for The Unicorn (2018)

Kate McKinnon, Nicholas Rutherford, and Nikki Reed

Nicholas Rutherford, Lucy Hale, Lauren Lapkus, Dree Hemingway, and Beck Bennett in The Unicorn (2018)

Nicholas Rutherford and Lauren Lapkus in The Unicorn (2018)