Tatiana Romanova: Difference between revisions
→Analysis: added reference |
|||
| Line 63: | Line 63: | ||
{{DEFAULTSORT:Romanova, Tatiana}} |
{{DEFAULTSORT:Romanova, Tatiana}} |
||
[[Category:Bond girls]] |
[[Category:Bond girls]] |
||
[[Category:Bond villains]] |
|||
[[Category:Fictional corporals]] |
[[Category:Fictional corporals]] |
||
[[Category:Fictional Russian people]] |
[[Category:Fictional Russian people]] |
||
| Line 72: | Line 71: | ||
[[Category:Literary characters introduced in 1957]] |
[[Category:Literary characters introduced in 1957]] |
||
[[Category:Characters in British novels of the 20th century]] |
[[Category:Characters in British novels of the 20th century]] |
||
[[Category:Action film villains]] |
|||
Revision as of 08:24, 14 October 2021
 | This article relies largely or entirely on a single source. (June 2021) |
| Tatiana Romanova | |
|---|---|
| James Bond character | |
 | |
| Created by | Ian Fleming |
| Portrayed by | Daniela Bianchi (film) |
| Voiced by | Barbara Jefford (film) Kari Wahlgren (video game) |
| In-universe information | |
| Gender | Female |
| Affiliation | KGB (novel) and SPECTRE (film) |
| Classification | Bond girl / Henchman |
Tatiana Alexeievna Romanova is a fictional character in the 1957 James Bond novel From Russia, with Love, its 1963 film adaptation and the 2005 video game based on both. She is played by Daniela Bianchi in the movie, with her voice dubbed in by Barbara Jefford.
Novel and film biography
Tatiana Alexeievna Romanova is introduced as a corporal in Soviet Army Intelligence, assigned to work in the Soviet consulate in Istanbul as a cipher clerk. Her superiors, in connection with SMERSH, plan to sow dissension in the intelligence community by murdering and discrediting a significant figure in western intelligence. The target was James Bond.
Her commanding officer is Rosa Klebb—in the screenplay adaptation, Klebb is secretly an agent for SPECTRE—who manipulates Romanova into believing that she is on an important mission for her country, when she is in fact merely a pawn in the terrorist organization's latest bid to destroy MI6.
In the novel, Klebb is actually a member of the Soviet government, commander in chief of the Otdyel II section of SMERSH. Romanova's mission is to seduce Bond and have him take her to England to deliver a code machine (a Spektor in the novel, a Lektor in the film), as well as plant false information, before being rescued from prison and returned to Russia. She is promised a promotion to Captain if she completes the mission.
Once in Istanbul, she contacts Darko Kerim (Ali Kerim Bey in the film) and tells him her plans: she will voluntarily defect from the Soviet Union and take the machine with her only if Bond assists in the operation. She claims to have fallen in love with Bond and developed a desire to live with him after seeing his picture in a secret file.
Both M and Bond believe the offer to be a trap, but the prize is valuable enough to go for it. They react just as the main instigator of the plot, chess champion Kronsteen, had predicted. Bond then flies to Istanbul and contacts Kerim, spending several days there and waiting for contact. After a riot at a Gypsy camp, Bond returns to his hotel room and finds Romanova walking across the room and getting into his bed, wearing only a black velvet choker and black stockings. They make love, but are secretly filmed by Klebb's minions via a one-way mirror. The film is meant to be used to embarrass MI6.
In the film, after meeting her again to verify the authenticity of her information, they blow up the Soviet consulate in Istanbul to cover their escape. With the help of Kerim, they board the Orient Express and depart for Trieste and the Italian frontier. As a part of Kronsteen's strategy, the SMERSH/SPECTRE assassin Donovan 'Red' Grant kills Kerim. Bond contacts Grant, who is pretending to be an agent named Nash. After sedating Romanova, Nash reveals his identity to Bond, who then fights Grant in their train compartment. Prior to the fight, Grant explains that he is going to kill Bond and then execute the sleeping Romanova with Bond's gun, making it look like a murder-suicide. Bond finally defeats Grant and takes Romanova to Venice. It is there they meet Klebb again who, in an attempt to retrieve the LEKTOR and kill Bond, disguises herself as a maid and tries to eliminate the agent with a dagger-tipped shoe poisoned with blowfish venom. Romanova shoots Klebb, thus saving Bond. She and Bond are last seen on a boat in Venice, with Bond dropping the incriminating film into the canal.
Similarly, in the novel, they board the Orient Express with Kerim, planning to travel to England over the course of four days. Kerim, instead of being killed by Grant, is killed by a Russian agent named Benz who had boarded the train earlier and also is killed in the struggle. This prompts the bombing of the Soviet consulate in Istanbul in retaliation. Despite this, Bond elects not to leave the train for a plane or the consulate, after having fallen for Romanova and not wanting to cut their time short. Grant pretends to be Nash, an MI6 agent sent by M in response to the death of Kerim. After sedating Romanova, under the guise of standing guard over Bond, he waits until they are both asleep, and plans to murder them. However, due to his vanity, he taunts Bond, revealing details of a meeting with Rosa Klebb. This allows Bond to disarm Grant and save Romanova's life. It is unclear as to what ultimately becomes of Tatiana in the novel as in her last appearance, she is still heavily affected by the sedatives, sleeping in the British consulate, while Bond confronts Klebb. It is presumed that she has been arrested and/or released by the British.
Analysis
The characters of Romanova and Grant exist in juxtaposition to one another with both being defectors from their respective nations, and it was the intention of Fleming in writing From Russia with Love to contrast these two characters as a way of justifying the moral superiority of Great Britain over the Soviet Union.[1] In the 1950s, there were real fears in the West that Communism might be the more efficient system, and the Soviet Union would pull ahead both economically and technologically over the West. Additionally, the Burgess-Maclean affair of 1951 when two senior British diplomats, Donald Maclean and Guy Burgess defected to the Soviet Union added to these fears.[2] At the time, it was not widely known that Maclean and Burgess were spies for the Soviet Union and in case of Maclean was on the brink of being arrested on charges of treason. The Soviet government claimed that Maclean and Burgess had defected because life was better in the Soviet Union while the British government was content to go along with this explanation rather than admit that two senior diplomats had been spies for the Soviet Union for the better part of the last twenty years. Since Maclean and Burgess were both members of "the Establishment", having attended public schools and Cambridge University, the defection of the two attracted much attention at the time.[3] Fleming's intention in writing From Russia with love was at least in part to promote a "West is the best" message by creating two parallel characters who would prove Western superiority over the Soviet Union.[3] Throughout the novel, Fleming drew contrasts between the Soviet Union and the West, always to the benefit of the latter.[2] For an example, the officers of SMERSH are portrayed as living in fear of their superiors while relations between MI6 officers are shown as warm and friendly.[2]
Romanova's life in Moscow as a low-ranking clerk for the MGB is portrayed as dull, confiding, and stifling as she lives a life of mind-numbing bureaucratic drudgery.[4] As a member of the MGB, Romanova enjoys a relatively privileged life in Moscow, but complains that her MGB uniform makes it hard for her to make friends as people fear her.[4] All of Romanova's superiors are portrayed as twisted and hideous-Rosa Klebb is an ugly woman with a "toad-like figure" and a lesbian while Kronsteen is a bisexual who is labelled "a monster" in the book.[5] The book makes it clear that people such as Klebb and Kronsteen are the norm in the Soviet system.[5] in the 1950s, homosexuality and bisexuality were widely considered to be perversions and Fleming by making most of his non-Russian characters straight in contrast to most of the Russian characters were part of his strategy to show "the West is the best".[5]
However despite her repulsive superiors in the MGB, she is portrayed as a committed Communist who is at the same time vaguely unhappy with her existence as Fleming wrote: "The Romanov blood might well have given a yearning for men other than that type of modern Russian officer she would meet-stern, cold, mechanical, basically hysterical and because of their Party education infernally dull".[5] Upon meeting Bond, she abandons her belief in Communism as she sees the advantage to a Western lifestyle while also finding Bond a much better lover than her Russian lovers.[5] Romanova falling in love with Bond is portrayed as both a political and sexual liberation for her.[5] The way that Bond literally and metaphorically seduces Romanova over to the West was meant by Fleming to prove the superiority of the Western world and western political ideologies.[5] Romanova even prefers Bond for his smell as Fleming portrays Russian men as refusing to bath and hence have unpleasant body odours.[5] The book's message that only men from the West like Bond can really sexually satisfy Romanova was another aspect of Fleming's "the West is the best" message.[5]
In contrast to Romanova who chooses life in the West over life in the Soviet Union, the book's villain, Grant, goes in the opposition direction.[5] Grant is described as a man from Northern Ireland who joins the British Army in the late 1940s which briefly checks his insanity and his love of killing.[5] After Grant is disciplined for his vicious style as a boxer, he decides to defect to the Soviet Union as: "He liked all he heard about the Russians, their brutality, their carelessness of human life, and their guile and he decided to go over to them".[6] Grant rides over on a motorcycle to a Red Army post in East Germany and says: "I am expert in killing people. I do it very well. I like it".[6] Grant narrowly avoids being executed out of hand by the Russians, who eventually decide to accept his offer. Having proven himself, he becomes the top assassin for SMERSH, who happily kills because he is insane and because killing is the only thing he knows how to do well.[6] In contrast to the soft and feminine Romanova who deep down really wants to be in love with a man which causes her to choose the West despite her privileged existence in Moscow, the hard and masculine Grant chooses the East because it is the only system where a perverted, violent man like himself can flourish.[7]
The 1963 film somewhat altered the novel's message by making SPECTRE rather than SMERSH as the main antagonist.[8] The Grant of the film is depoliticised, becoming a murderer who was acquitted by reason of insanity who then escapes from a mental institution and comes to serve as an assassin for a criminal organisation instead of a soldier who broke his oath to serve King and Country by defecting to the Soviet Union.[8] The Romanova of the film is much closer to the Romanova of the book who is shown as thoroughly enjoying the consumerist lifestyle of the West who is constantly buying expensive clothing that Bond introduces her to.[8] Like in the book, her relationship with Bond serves as both a political and a sexual liberation.[8] Unlike in the book, Romanova of the film makes a more clear decision to choose the West by shooting Klebb in the film's climax to save Bond, a decision made more significant as Romanova is unaware that Klebb is really working for SPECTRE.[8] The theme of defection does not play the same central role in the film as it does in the novel.[8] The film's message that the obsessive struggle between MI6 and the MGB allows a criminal organisation like SPECTRE to flourish seems to be a criticism of the Cold War.[8] The Cuban Missile Crisis of 1962 had just occurred the previous year, and the film's message is that through the Soviet Union might be an enemy, it is best to keep the level of hostilities down to a manageable level.[8] The fact that Romanova in the film as in the book chooses the West was meant to prove Western superiority, but at the same time the film seems to be cautioning against her excessively anti-Communist policies.[9]
According to Cubby Broccoli, Ian Fleming modelled Romanova on Anna Kutusova, a Russian involved in the Metro-Vickers Affair.[10]
Other media
The character's role in the video game adaptation of From Russia With Love is more or less the same as in the novel and film, the only major difference being that she is now an unwitting double agent for a terrorist organization called "OCTOPUS". She is voiced by Kari Wahlgren.
The character also appears in the 1993 James Bond comic book that takes place after the events of From Russia With Love, called Light of My Death, in which she is reinstated as KGB agent, aiding Bond in his mission against a shadowy villain who wants to provoke a war between the Soviets and the West.
Books and articles
- Takors, Jones (2010). "'The Russians could not longer be the heavies' From Russia with Love and the Cold War in the Bond Series". In Barbara Korte; Eva Ulrike Pirker & Sissy Helff (eds.). Facing the East in the West: Images of Eastern Europe in British Literature, Film and Culture. London: Rodopi. pp. 219–232. ISBN 9042030496.
References
- ^ Takors 2010, p. 222.
- ^ a b c Takors 2010, p. 221.
- ^ a b Takors 2010, p. 220-221.
- ^ a b Takors 2010, p. 223-224.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Takors 2010, p. 224.
- ^ a b c Takors 2010, p. 225.
- ^ Takors 2010, p. 226.
- ^ a b c d e f g h Takors 2010, p. 229.
- ^ Takors 2010, p. 229-230.
- ^ Broccoli, Albert R. (1998). When the Snow Melts: The Autobiography of Cubby Broccoli. Boxtree. p. 184.
