Talk:Valencian: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
No edit summary |
|||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
I would like to create a disambiguation page in the same way as [[English]], [[Spanish]] or [[Portuguese]]. I know there are lots of links that need to be corrected... As you can see, I and another user started doing that before being reverted, this should be completed at some point so it shouldn't be a problem to object to proceed to the creation of the Valencian disambiguation page. One reason to create this disambiguation page is the separation of Valencian language and Valencian people. IMO it isn't professional to have Valencian redirecting to the language and Valencians to the article that covers the native people of Valencia, the same term can't be split by its plural form, since Valencian is a also part of the people. Other terms involved is the Valencian national identity and the culture which could have a link. — [[User:Nuvolet]] <sup>([[User talk:Nuvolet|''dis-me'']])</sup> 18:17, 26 November 2021 (UTC) |
I would like to create a disambiguation page in the same way as [[English]], [[Spanish]] or [[Portuguese]]. I know there are lots of links that need to be corrected... As you can see, I and another user started doing that before being reverted, this should be completed at some point so it shouldn't be a problem to object to proceed to the creation of the Valencian disambiguation page. One reason to create this disambiguation page is the separation of Valencian language and Valencian people. IMO it isn't professional to have Valencian redirecting to the language and Valencians to the article that covers the native people of Valencia, the same term can't be split by its plural form, since Valencian is a also part of the people. Other terms involved is the Valencian national identity and the culture which could have a link. — [[User:Nuvolet]] <sup>([[User talk:Nuvolet|''dis-me'']])</sup> 18:17, 26 November 2021 (UTC) |
||
:I'm correcting the links and all I can see the Valencian municipality articles are way too chaotic. The infobox is not uniform and the info is too messy sometimes. In my opinion, they need attention... It's sad to see there is not a more organised approach here, even the link Valencian by itself shows not many care too much about these topics. The language is another problem, there seems to be problems fully accepting Valencian and its diffusion. — [[User:Nuvolet]] <sup>([[User talk:Nuvolet|''dis-me'']])</sup> 22:41, 26 November 2021 (UTC) |
:I'm correcting the links and all I can see the Valencian municipality articles are way too chaotic. The infobox is not uniform and the info is too messy sometimes. In my opinion, they need attention... It's sad to see there is not a more organised approach here, even the link Valencian by itself shows not many care too much about these topics. The language is another problem, there seems to be problems fully accepting Valencian and its diffusion. — [[User:Nuvolet]] <sup>([[User talk:Nuvolet|''dis-me'']])</sup> 22:41, 26 November 2021 (UTC) |
||
:I see no consensus here to turn this redirect into a disambiguation page. Therefore, any change of {{code|[[Valencian]]}} to {{code|[[Valencian language|Valencian]]}} is pointless and undesirable, per [[WP:NOTBROKEN]]. There is no ambiguity when linking to this redirect as far as Wikipedia is concerned, it just adds unnecessary text into article. |
|||
:With that being said, I support the change provided that it's done right - unless the term ''Valencian'' is most usually used in English to refer to the language, rather than anything else. [[User:Sol505000|Sol505000]] ([[User talk:Sol505000|talk]]) 06:37, 28 November 2021 (UTC) |
|||
Revision as of 06:37, 28 November 2021
Disambiguation page
I would like to create a disambiguation page in the same way as English, Spanish or Portuguese. I know there are lots of links that need to be corrected... As you can see, I and another user started doing that before being reverted, this should be completed at some point so it shouldn't be a problem to object to proceed to the creation of the Valencian disambiguation page. One reason to create this disambiguation page is the separation of Valencian language and Valencian people. IMO it isn't professional to have Valencian redirecting to the language and Valencians to the article that covers the native people of Valencia, the same term can't be split by its plural form, since Valencian is a also part of the people. Other terms involved is the Valencian national identity and the culture which could have a link. — User:Nuvolet (dis-me) 18:17, 26 November 2021 (UTC)
- I'm correcting the links and all I can see the Valencian municipality articles are way too chaotic. The infobox is not uniform and the info is too messy sometimes. In my opinion, they need attention... It's sad to see there is not a more organised approach here, even the link Valencian by itself shows not many care too much about these topics. The language is another problem, there seems to be problems fully accepting Valencian and its diffusion. — User:Nuvolet (dis-me) 22:41, 26 November 2021 (UTC)
- I see no consensus here to turn this redirect into a disambiguation page. Therefore, any change of
[[Valencian]]to[[Valencian language|Valencian]]is pointless and undesirable, per WP:NOTBROKEN. There is no ambiguity when linking to this redirect as far as Wikipedia is concerned, it just adds unnecessary text into article. - With that being said, I support the change provided that it's done right - unless the term Valencian is most usually used in English to refer to the language, rather than anything else. Sol505000 (talk) 06:37, 28 November 2021 (UTC)
