Talk:Apollo 440: Difference between revisions
Pinkgothic (talk | contribs) →Soundtracks: : Organising a deadline for discussion |
Pinkgothic (talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
Hmm. This bothers me a bit - the three new soundtrack entries. '''Antigrav''' and '''Rapid Racer''' are exclusives - no other band ''but'' Apollo 440 contributed to those two soundtracks. In regards to Gran Tourismo, even though I do not own any of those games, I'm fairly certain this is not the case. So, to differentiate: New section? If so, there's a problem, namely that Apollo 440 songs are on a insane multitude of soundtracks, paticularily of movies. The Jackal, Resident Evil, Schlaraffenland, Lost in Space, et cetera come to mind. It'd be nuts to list them all. |
Hmm. This bothers me a bit - the three new soundtrack entries. '''Antigrav''' and '''Rapid Racer''' are exclusives - no other band ''but'' Apollo 440 contributed to those two soundtracks. In regards to Gran Tourismo, even though I do not own any of those games, I'm fairly certain this is not the case. So, to differentiate: New section? If so, there's a problem, namely that Apollo 440 songs are on a insane multitude of soundtracks, paticularily of movies. The Jackal, Resident Evil, Schlaraffenland, Lost in Space, et cetera come to mind. It'd be nuts to list them all. |
||
So, in light of that, let's work out the criteria for Soundtrack listings here, and whether or not a differentiation (e.g. -'''Soundtracks''' offers both '''Exclusive''' and '''Partial''' section listings) is a good idea. I was just about to differentiate when the above mentioned problematic became clear to me. Thoughts? |
So, in light of that, let's work out the criteria for Soundtrack listings here, and whether or not a differentiation (e.g. -'''Soundtracks''' offers both '''Exclusive''' and '''Partial''' section listings) is a good idea. I was just about to differentiate when the above mentioned problematic became clear to me. Thoughts? |
||
Fact is, for now, I've done the differentiation, and put in a note about the discussion regarding the topic in the '''Partial''' section, but I'll be happy to change this back to a simple soundtrack listing, given, of course, a reason. [[User:Pinkgothic|pinkgothic]] 20:06, 16 August 2005 (UTC) |
|||
:As an add-on thought: If there is no response in regards to this topic within a month, I will simply revert the entry to read only the exclusives again, aswell as a reference to there being many partial soundtrack contributions. I would not announce this or even plan it if I hadn't been watching this page forever and noticed very few larger changes - I would like feedback, but I don't want the page frozen in a state that's just simply bad (inconsistent) style. [[User:Pinkgothic|pinkgothic]] 20:10, 16 August 2005 (UTC) |
:As an add-on thought: If there is no response in regards to this topic within a month, I will simply revert the entry to read only the exclusives again, aswell as a reference to there being many partial soundtrack contributions. I would not announce this or even plan it if I hadn't been watching this page forever and noticed very few larger changes - I would like feedback, but I don't want the page frozen in a state that's just simply bad (inconsistent) style. [[User:Pinkgothic|pinkgothic]] 20:10, 16 August 2005 (UTC) |
||
Revision as of 20:19, 16 August 2005
Soundtracks
Hmm. This bothers me a bit - the three new soundtrack entries. Antigrav and Rapid Racer are exclusives - no other band but Apollo 440 contributed to those two soundtracks. In regards to Gran Tourismo, even though I do not own any of those games, I'm fairly certain this is not the case. So, to differentiate: New section? If so, there's a problem, namely that Apollo 440 songs are on a insane multitude of soundtracks, paticularily of movies. The Jackal, Resident Evil, Schlaraffenland, Lost in Space, et cetera come to mind. It'd be nuts to list them all.
So, in light of that, let's work out the criteria for Soundtrack listings here, and whether or not a differentiation (e.g. -Soundtracks offers both Exclusive and Partial section listings) is a good idea. I was just about to differentiate when the above mentioned problematic became clear to me. Thoughts?
Fact is, for now, I've done the differentiation, and put in a note about the discussion regarding the topic in the Partial section, but I'll be happy to change this back to a simple soundtrack listing, given, of course, a reason. pinkgothic 20:06, 16 August 2005 (UTC)
- As an add-on thought: If there is no response in regards to this topic within a month, I will simply revert the entry to read only the exclusives again, aswell as a reference to there being many partial soundtrack contributions. I would not announce this or even plan it if I hadn't been watching this page forever and noticed very few larger changes - I would like feedback, but I don't want the page frozen in a state that's just simply bad (inconsistent) style. pinkgothic 20:10, 16 August 2005 (UTC)
