Commons:Freedom of Panorama 2015/cz
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
This is the overview of the Freedom of Panorama dicussion in media in the Czech Republic.
Political positions
[edit]- Czech Greens: FoP must be protected
- Pirate Party: FoP must be protected
- KDU-ČSL (Christian Democrats):
- MEP Pavel Svoboda: (earlier) These news are hoax, nothing will be changed. (later) FoP is a communist freedom. (even later): FoP is something Facebook and Google profits from and not NGOs.
- MEP Tomáš Zdechovský: Why JURI regulates such an absurdity?
- Pavel Bělobrádek (party chairman): It's a hoax.
- Free Party (SSO).
- Karel Zvára: Vice chairman: It is a real threat and it is good that Wikipedians are alarmed.
- MEP Petr Mach: Another EU-nonsense.
- Social Democrats: unknown
- MEP Pavel Poc: It's just a preliminary report. As an amateur photographer i will be against this non-sense.
- Zdeněk Škromach (vice-chairman of Czech Senate): They got crazy in BXL.
- TOP 09: unknown
- Youth TOP 09 support the restrictions on FoP.
- Luděk Niedermayer supports the restrictions on FoP (told by e-mail) --Mirefek (talk) 13:45, 7 July 2015 (UTC)
- ANO 2011:
- Pavel Telička: FoP must be protected, we need to contact ALDE members who voted for for explanation
- KSČM (Communists)
- MEP Jiří Maštálka: I support freedom and common sense, but the media storm too exaggarated.
- MEP Kateřina Konečná: "jsme pro její zachování"
Other involved subjects
[edit]- Photographers were asked by media
- EDUin
- IuRe (an EDRI member)
- ??
Online polls
[edit]As of 20. 6., out of 8985 people voted 98 % for FOP and only 2 % were against (E15 online poll).
FoP articles
[edit]Against FoP
[edit]Pavel Svoboda's press releases
[edit]- http://blog.aktualne.cz/blogy/pavel-svoboda.php?itemid=25435 Svoboda blog, 18.6.2015
- http://kdu.cz/aktualne/zpravy/pavel-svoboda-fotit-si-samozrejme-muze-kazdy-to,-c, 18. 6. 2015.
- http://www.euractiv.cz/obchod-a-export0/clanek/konec-fotografovani-na-ulici-je-to-nesmysl-shoduji-se-cesti-europoslanci-012715 18. 6. 2015
Supporting FoP
[edit]11. 6.
[edit]17. 6.
[edit]- http://www.zeleni.cz/evropsky-parlament-se-chysta-zabit-svobodne-fotografovani/, 17. 6. 2015
- http://www.krajskelisty.cz/praha/9935-europoslanci-si-asi-spletli-stoleti-chteji-zrusit-svobodu-fotografovani-na-ulici-varuji-cesti-pirati-prudte-hlavne-politiky-co-pro-tu-blbost-pleduji-radi-bartos.htm, 17. 6. 2015
- http://zpravy.e15.cz/domaci/udalosti/smite-fotografovat-na-ulici-ne-navrhl-europarlament-1200644, 17. 6. 2015 (this news story was a trigger in Czech media)
- http://www.kurzy.cz/zpravy/381969-omezime-svobodu-fotografovani-navrhuje-brusel/, 17. 6. 2015
- http://ekonomicky-denik.cz/omezime-svobodu-fotografovani-navrhuje-brusel/, 17. 6. 2015
- http://tn.nova.cz/clanek/bruselsti-urednici-uz-se-uplne-zblaznili-chteji-zakazat-foceni.html 17. 6 2015
18. 6.
[edit]- https://www.blesk.cz/clanek/zpravy-komentare/325799/fotka-z-prazdnin-na-facebooku-zaplatis-honorar-v-bruselu-uz-omezeni-plati.html, 18. 6. 2015 (highly pro-Wiki)
- https://www.blesk.cz/clanek/zpravy-udalosti/325860/kdo-vyfoti-nocni-eifelovku-na-facebook-porusuje-zakon-europoslanec-haji-zakaz-foceni-na-ulici.html, 18. 6. 2015
- http://www.halonoviny.cz/articles/view/38694398, 18. 6. 2015
- http://www.cnews.cz/clanky/padne-svoboda-panoramatu-na-pude-eu-se-resi-zakaz-komercniho-foceni-budov-soch, 18. 6. 2015
19. 6.
[edit]- http://pctuning.tyden.cz/multimedia/16-elektronika/35447-eu-umelecka-dila-na-ulicich-nam-proste-fotit-nebudete (most pro-wiki complex article)
20. 6.
[edit]23. 6.
[edit]- http://www.novinky.cz/domaci/373066-zverejnovat-fotky-budov-treba-z-dovolene-ma-byt-trestne.html
- http://www.parlamentnilisty.cz/politika/politici-volicum/Telicka-ANO-Nevidim-duvod-proc-omezit-svobodu-panoramatu-Prekvapilo-me-to-380620
26. 6.
[edit]- Kováč, Peter (2015-06-26). "Jak to bude se svobodou fotografování?". Právo: 7.
Neutral
[edit]- http://www.parlamentnilisty.cz/politika/politici-volicum/Europoslanec-Jiri-Mastalka-Brod-je-jeste-daleko-380241, 18. 6. 2015
- http://digiarena.e15.cz/fotografovani-verejnych-mist-jako-zlocin-eu-jako-kat/?textart=1#utm_medium=selfpromo&utm_source=digiarena&utm_campaign=RSSfeed 19. 6. 2015
- http://www.rozhlas.cz/ostrava/poznamka/_zprava/frantisek-tichy-svoboda-panoramatu--1503747
- http://zahranicni.eurozpravy.cz/eu/123813-jak-je-to-se-zakazem-fotografovani-europoslanec-sdelil-detaily/
- Neff, Ondřej (2015-06-24). "Povyk kolem Eiffelovky". Lidové noviny: 10.
European Commission
[edit]- http://ec.europa.eu/ceskarepublika/news/150618_fotografovani_pred_budovami_cs.htm 18. 6. 2015 (EC is not being neutral in backing the opinion of Pavel Svoboda that social networks do not consider commercial use and citizens have no reason to be worried)
Banners
[edit]
Alternative:
Alternative 2:
Návrh v Evropském parlamentu by vyžadoval odstranění tisíců fotografií moderních budov a soch z Wikipedie.
