Margitte's Reviews > The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks
The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks
by
by
Margitte's review
bookshelves: african-american, american-author, american-history, biography-and-memoir, nonfiction, reviewed
Jan 19, 2017
bookshelves: african-american, american-author, american-history, biography-and-memoir, nonfiction, reviewed
The gift of life is surely the greatest gift of all. So how can the story of the remarkable woman who gave that gift over and over again to millions of people have been overlooked for so long?
In 1951 a poor African American woman in Maryland became an uninformed donor to medical science. Henrietta Lacks died at age 31 of cervical cancer at John Hopkins hospital in Baltimore. Then doctors discovered that tumor cells they had removed from her body earlier continued to thrive in the lab - a medical first.
Before long, her cells, dubbed HeLa cells, would be used for research around the world, contributing to major advances in everything from cancer treatments to vaccines; from aging to the life cycle of mosquitoes; nuclear bomb explosions to effect of gravity on human tissue during flights to outer space. An estimated 50 million metric tons of her cells were reproduced; thousands of careers have been build, and initiated more than 60 000 scientific studies until now, but Henrietta Lacks never gave permission for that research, nor had her family.
In The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks, Rebecca Skloot gracefully tells the story of the real woman and her descendants; the history of race-related medical research, including the role of eugenics; the struggles of the Lacks family with poverty, politics and racial issues; the phenomenal development of science based on the HeLa cells, in a language that can be understood by everyone. She combined the family's story with the changing ethics and laws around tissue collection, the irresponsible use of the family's medical information by journalists and researchers and the legislation preventing the family from benefiting from it all.
COMMENTS
I was gifted this book in December but never realized the impact it had internationally, neither would have on me. Until I finished reading it last night, I did not know it was an international bestseller, as well as read by so many of my GR friends! It was total surprise, since nonfiction is normally not a regular star on bestseller lists, right?
The debate around the moral issue, and the experiences of the poor family were very well presented in the book, which was truly well written and objective as far as possible.
For me personally, the question of how this woman, who basically saved millions of people's lives, were overlooked, is answered in the arrogance of scientists who deemed it unnecessary to respect the rights of people unable to fend for themselves.
The ethical and moral dilemmas it created in America, when the family became aware of their mother's contribution to science without anyone's knowledge or consent, just enabled the commercial enterprises who benefited massively from her cells, to move to other countries where human rights are just a faint star in a unlimited universe. The Lacks family drew a line in the sand of how far people must be exploited in America. Unfortunately the medical fraternity just moved their operations elsewhere.
Tissue and organ harvesting thrive in the world, it is globally a massive industry, with the poorest of the poor still the uninformed donors. An open secret. There are numerous stories, especially in India, where people wake up and realize they were operated on and one of their organs is missing. Stolen. By the time they became aware of it, the organ had already been transplanted in America and elsewhere in the world. That's no secret.
Everything is justified as long as science is involved.
Nowadays people in other parts of the world sell their organs, even though it is illegal in most countries. According to American laws people cannot sell their tissue, which is part of human organs? People can donate it though, then it is acceptable.Yet someone else can patent your cells, but you're not allowed to be compensated, since the minute it leaves your body, it is regarded as waste, disposed of, and therefor not deemed your 'property' anymore. Huh?
This book was a good and necessary read. The human interest side of it, telling the story of the family was eye-opening and excellent. A little bit of melodramatic, but how else would it become a bestseller, if ordinary readers like us could not relate to it. It was very well-written indeed.
Thanks to Rebecca Skloot, in 2010, sixty years later, HeLa now has a history, a face and an address. Finally, Henrietta Lacks, and not the anonymous HeLa, became a biological celebrity.
In 1951 Dr. Grey's lab assistant handled yet just another tissue sample of hundreds, when she received Henrietta's to prepare for research. She named it HeLa(first two letters of the patient's name and last name). But a few months later she visited the body of the deceased Henrietta Lacks in the mortuary to collect more samples. When she saw the woman's red-painted toenails, a lightbulb went on.
Nevertheless, this book should be read by everybody. Without it the world would have been a lot poorer and less human.
The world has a lot to answer for.
RECOMMENDED for sure!
EDIT
I googled the Lacks family and landed upon the website of the Lacks Foundation, which was started by Rebecca Skloot.
http://henriettalacksfoundation.org/
That news TOTALLY made my day. I wish them all the best and hope they will succeed in their goals and dreams. A wonderful initiative. Just imagine what can be accomplished if every single person, organization, research facility and medical company who benefitted for Henrietta Lacks's tissue cells, donate only $1 (one single dollar)? Yes, just imagine that!
So many positive things happened to the family after the book was published. It just brings tears of joy to my eyes.
http://www.lacksfamily.net/index.php
And finally:
May 29, 2010
A Historic Day: Henrietta Lacks’s Long Unmarked Grave Finally Gets a Headstone
thanks to Dr. Roland Pattillo at Morehouse School of Medicine, who donated a headstone after reading The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks.
In 1951 a poor African American woman in Maryland became an uninformed donor to medical science. Henrietta Lacks died at age 31 of cervical cancer at John Hopkins hospital in Baltimore. Then doctors discovered that tumor cells they had removed from her body earlier continued to thrive in the lab - a medical first.
Before long, her cells, dubbed HeLa cells, would be used for research around the world, contributing to major advances in everything from cancer treatments to vaccines; from aging to the life cycle of mosquitoes; nuclear bomb explosions to effect of gravity on human tissue during flights to outer space. An estimated 50 million metric tons of her cells were reproduced; thousands of careers have been build, and initiated more than 60 000 scientific studies until now, but Henrietta Lacks never gave permission for that research, nor had her family.
In The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks, Rebecca Skloot gracefully tells the story of the real woman and her descendants; the history of race-related medical research, including the role of eugenics; the struggles of the Lacks family with poverty, politics and racial issues; the phenomenal development of science based on the HeLa cells, in a language that can be understood by everyone. She combined the family's story with the changing ethics and laws around tissue collection, the irresponsible use of the family's medical information by journalists and researchers and the legislation preventing the family from benefiting from it all.
COMMENTS
I was gifted this book in December but never realized the impact it had internationally, neither would have on me. Until I finished reading it last night, I did not know it was an international bestseller, as well as read by so many of my GR friends! It was total surprise, since nonfiction is normally not a regular star on bestseller lists, right?
The debate around the moral issue, and the experiences of the poor family were very well presented in the book, which was truly well written and objective as far as possible.
For me personally, the question of how this woman, who basically saved millions of people's lives, were overlooked, is answered in the arrogance of scientists who deemed it unnecessary to respect the rights of people unable to fend for themselves.
The ethical and moral dilemmas it created in America, when the family became aware of their mother's contribution to science without anyone's knowledge or consent, just enabled the commercial enterprises who benefited massively from her cells, to move to other countries where human rights are just a faint star in a unlimited universe. The Lacks family drew a line in the sand of how far people must be exploited in America. Unfortunately the medical fraternity just moved their operations elsewhere.
Tissue and organ harvesting thrive in the world, it is globally a massive industry, with the poorest of the poor still the uninformed donors. An open secret. There are numerous stories, especially in India, where people wake up and realize they were operated on and one of their organs is missing. Stolen. By the time they became aware of it, the organ had already been transplanted in America and elsewhere in the world. That's no secret.
Everything is justified as long as science is involved.
Nowadays people in other parts of the world sell their organs, even though it is illegal in most countries. According to American laws people cannot sell their tissue, which is part of human organs? People can donate it though, then it is acceptable.Yet someone else can patent your cells, but you're not allowed to be compensated, since the minute it leaves your body, it is regarded as waste, disposed of, and therefor not deemed your 'property' anymore. Huh?
This book was a good and necessary read. The human interest side of it, telling the story of the family was eye-opening and excellent. A little bit of melodramatic, but how else would it become a bestseller, if ordinary readers like us could not relate to it. It was very well-written indeed.
Thanks to Rebecca Skloot, in 2010, sixty years later, HeLa now has a history, a face and an address. Finally, Henrietta Lacks, and not the anonymous HeLa, became a biological celebrity.
In 1951 Dr. Grey's lab assistant handled yet just another tissue sample of hundreds, when she received Henrietta's to prepare for research. She named it HeLa(first two letters of the patient's name and last name). But a few months later she visited the body of the deceased Henrietta Lacks in the mortuary to collect more samples. When she saw the woman's red-painted toenails, a lightbulb went on.
Mary Kubicek: “Oh jeez, she’s a real person. . . . I started imagining her sitting in her bathroom painting those toenails, and it hit me for the first time that those cells we’d been working with all this time and sending all over the world, they came from a live woman. I’d never thought of it that way.”John Hopkins hospital could have considered naming a wing of their research facilities after Henrietta Lack. Why don't they?
Nevertheless, this book should be read by everybody. Without it the world would have been a lot poorer and less human.
The world has a lot to answer for.
RECOMMENDED for sure!
EDIT
I googled the Lacks family and landed upon the website of the Lacks Foundation, which was started by Rebecca Skloot.
http://henriettalacksfoundation.org/
That news TOTALLY made my day. I wish them all the best and hope they will succeed in their goals and dreams. A wonderful initiative. Just imagine what can be accomplished if every single person, organization, research facility and medical company who benefitted for Henrietta Lacks's tissue cells, donate only $1 (one single dollar)? Yes, just imagine that!
So many positive things happened to the family after the book was published. It just brings tears of joy to my eyes.
http://www.lacksfamily.net/index.php
And finally:
May 29, 2010
A Historic Day: Henrietta Lacks’s Long Unmarked Grave Finally Gets a Headstone
thanks to Dr. Roland Pattillo at Morehouse School of Medicine, who donated a headstone after reading The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Started Reading
January 19, 2017
– Shelved
January 19, 2017
– Shelved as:
african-american
January 19, 2017
– Shelved as:
american-author
January 19, 2017
– Shelved as:
american-history
January 19, 2017
– Shelved as:
biography-and-memoir
January 19, 2017
– Shelved as:
nonfiction
January 19, 2017
– Shelved as:
reviewed
January 19, 2017
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-40 of 40 (40 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Sue
(new)
-
added it
Jan 19, 2017 10:24PM
This has been on my list for a while now. I guess it's time for me to get to reading it. Very nice review.
reply
|
flag
Sue wrote: "This has been on my list for a while now. I guess it's time for me to get to reading it. Very nice review."
Thank you Sue. It's really a great read. More than just a nonfictional representation of facts.
Thank you Sue. It's really a great read. More than just a nonfictional representation of facts.
It's been on my list for a while too , Margitte. Thanks for such s thoughtful review and the reminder that this is one I should read .
Really interesting review, Margitte. I'll have to move this one up, even though non-fiction usually isn't my thing.
Margitte..I most important quote from your review "Thanks to Rebecca Skloot, in 2010, sixty years later, HeLa now has a history, a face and an address. Finally, Henrietta Lacks, and not the anonymous HeLa, became a biological celebrity". Your review was spot on!
Angela M wrote: "It's been on my list for a while too , Margitte. Thanks for such s thoughtful review and the reminder that this is one I should read ."
Thank you Angela. I did not even really look at the book until yesterday - the cover was just not attractive enough. But I'm so glad I did not stack it somewhere. It really is a noteworthy book.
Thank you Angela. I did not even really look at the book until yesterday - the cover was just not attractive enough. But I'm so glad I did not stack it somewhere. It really is a noteworthy book.
Debbie wrote: "Really interesting review, Margitte. I'll have to move this one up, even though non-fiction usually isn't my thing."
I love nonfiction, but this one far exceeded the expectations, Debbie. If it wasn't so factually well researched, and real names used, it could have read like an almost novel.
I love nonfiction, but this one far exceeded the expectations, Debbie. If it wasn't so factually well researched, and real names used, it could have read like an almost novel.
Sonja wrote: "This is one of my all time favourite books ever! So glad you also enjoyed it"
I read your review, Sonja. You summed it up perfectly. Well this one can be a fantastic book club choice. There's so much to talk about, right?
I read your review, Sonja. You summed it up perfectly. Well this one can be a fantastic book club choice. There's so much to talk about, right?
Fran wrote: "Margitte.. The most important quote from your review "Thanks to Rebecca Skloot, in 2010, sixty years later, HeLa now has a history, a face and an address. Finally, Henrietta Lacks, and not the anonymo..."
I'm so proud of the ordinary people and her family who stood up for what was right, Fran. They finally got to honor a remarkable women. As far as I am concerned, an no matter what the scientists and medical industry get away with, they should be thoroughly ashamed of their history. That's me on my soapbox, sorry :-))
I'm so proud of the ordinary people and her family who stood up for what was right, Fran. They finally got to honor a remarkable women. As far as I am concerned, an no matter what the scientists and medical industry get away with, they should be thoroughly ashamed of their history. That's me on my soapbox, sorry :-))
Margitte wrote: "Fran wrote: "Margitte.. The most important quote from your review "Thanks to Rebecca Skloot, in 2010, sixty years later, HeLa now has a history, a face and an address. Finally, Henrietta Lacks, and..."
Well said Margitte.
Well said Margitte.
Great review, Margitte! This book sounds really interesting. I've added it to my list... Thank you for bringing it to my attention!
Jennifer wrote: "Great review, Margitte! This book sounds really interesting. I've added it to my list... Thank you for bringing it to my attention!"
Thanks Jennifer! It's a heartfelt experience through and through.
Thanks Jennifer! It's a heartfelt experience through and through.
I love seeing how this book touched you, Margitte! It is the February book of our art museum book club. I've been eager to read it, even more so now seeing your review.
On a related note, Oprah Winfrey has just produced (and acted in) a movie based on this book. My cousin's wife was one of the on-site producers. It should be released some time this year. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt5686132/
On a related note, Oprah Winfrey has just produced (and acted in) a movie based on this book. My cousin's wife was one of the on-site producers. It should be released some time this year. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt5686132/
Suzy wrote: "I love seeing how this book touched you, Margitte! It is the February book of our art museum book club. I've been eager to read it, even more so now seeing your review.
On a related note, Oprah Wi..."
I watched an interview with Oprah, although very brief, about her movie (interview was in 2013) I hope it is a popular movie. I would love to see it.
I want to recommend this book to our book club as well, Suzy.
You must enjoy every minute! :-)
On a related note, Oprah Wi..."
I watched an interview with Oprah, although very brief, about her movie (interview was in 2013) I hope it is a popular movie. I would love to see it.
I want to recommend this book to our book club as well, Suzy.
You must enjoy every minute! :-)
Margitte wrote: "Suzy wrote: "I love seeing how this book touched you, Margitte! It is the February book of our art museum book club. I've been eager to read it, even more so now seeing your review.
On a related no..."
I plan to enjoy the book and I assume the movie will be well-promoted and popular. The book was very popular here in the States when it was released, receiving many awards. I see it won an Audie for the audiobook, which is how I'm going to read it. Excited!
On a related no..."
I plan to enjoy the book and I assume the movie will be well-promoted and popular. The book was very popular here in the States when it was released, receiving many awards. I see it won an Audie for the audiobook, which is how I'm going to read it. Excited!
Wonderful review! I can't believe I have yet to read this one. Too many great books out these which is a beautiful thing.
PorshaJo wrote: "Wonderful review! I can't believe I have yet to read this one. Too many great books out these days which is a beautiful thing."
Thanks, Porsha. Yes, it is just amazing how well-written so many books are nowadays and sadly not enough readers for all of them.
Thanks, Porsha. Yes, it is just amazing how well-written so many books are nowadays and sadly not enough readers for all of them.
Jenny wrote: "Everyone should read this book.. amazing amazing book... and this is an amazing review!"
DITTO! DITTO! DITTO!
And thanks, Jenny.
DITTO! DITTO! DITTO!
And thanks, Jenny.
Fabulous review, Margitte, so in depth, I didn't know about the wing potentially being named after her - and you're right, they *should*... frankly I don't know what has taken them this long! This was an amazingly well done story, I was completely immersed in it when I read it. Since you didn't mention this, I wanted to let you know (if you didn't know this already) that there is an HBO movie of this book (maybe still being made) to be released this year.
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt5686132/
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt5686132/
Cheri wrote: "Fabulous review, Margitte, so in depth, I didn't know about the wing potentially being named after her - and you're right, they *should*... frankly I don't know what has taken them this long! This ..."
Thank you, Cheri. Oprah made the movie with her in the lead role, playing Deborah Lacks, right?
John Hopkins Hospital does not consider naming a research facility after Henrietta. I am of the opinion that they SHOULD do it. In fact the Statue Of Liberty should be renamed after her. Henrietta changed the lives of mankind. That's how I feel . :-)
Thank you, Cheri. Oprah made the movie with her in the lead role, playing Deborah Lacks, right?
John Hopkins Hospital does not consider naming a research facility after Henrietta. I am of the opinion that they SHOULD do it. In fact the Statue Of Liberty should be renamed after her. Henrietta changed the lives of mankind. That's how I feel . :-)
Margitte, Oprah is playing the role of Deborah Lacks, with Kyanna Simone playing Deborah in her younger years, Renée Elise Goldsberry is playing Henrietta Lacks, Rose Byrne plays Rebecca Skloot. There's others, too many to name, and I still don't know when this will air except sometime 2017!
You read the most diverse and interesting books! I love your generosity and eloquence and bringing to our attention so many interesting things. Unfortunately, the medicine has progressed by exploiting the poor, the unloved and unwanted. Writers like Skloot should be praised and aplauded.