PattyMacDotComma's Reviews > The Snow Child
The Snow Child
by
by
PattyMacDotComma's review
bookshelves: award-win-listed, fiction, favourites-adult, fantasy-folk-myth-super-magic
Jun 26, 2018
bookshelves: award-win-listed, fiction, favourites-adult, fantasy-folk-myth-super-magic
5★
“It was beautiful, Mabel knew, but it was a beauty that ripped you open and scoured you clean so that you were left helpless and exposed, if you lived at all.
. . .
Jack had always scoffed at the superstitious and mystical. Alone in the depths of the wilderness, however, in the fading winter light, he had discovered in himself an animal-like fear.”
A debut, a Pulitzer Prize nominee, and a wonderful story I’m happy to add to my list of favourites. I used to read myths and fairy tales, so I’m a perfect audience for this lovely interpretation of an old Russian folktale.
It's 1920, Wolverine River, Alaska. Jack and Mabel have made a daring move from the comfortable East Coast of the United States. Mabel was a well-educated, sheltered girl, but when she and Jack lost their baby and have had none since, she urged him to make the change. They needed to start anew, by themselves, for themselves. Or so she told people.
“. . . she wondered if she had told the truth. Was that why they had come north – to build a life? Or did fear drive her? Fear of the gray, not just in the strands of her hair and her wilting cheeks, but the gray that ran deeper, to the bone, so that she thought she might turn into a fine dust and simply sift away in the wind.”
Eventually the isolation, Jack’s troubles trying to farm, and their dwindling finances finally grind Mabel down, not to a fine dust, but to a state of despair.
She’s ready to call it quits, but then one day, they meet a neighbour family of lively boys and colourful parents, and they are sucked into their warm circle. Esther is a strong, loveable woman in overalls with a never-say-die attitude. Just what Mabel needs.
“Esther burst into the cabin like a friendly hen, flapping and chattering and nearly knocking Mabel over as she tried to open the door for her. In one hand she held a towel-covered cast-iron pot and with the other she hugged Mabel and kissed her on the cheek.”
When the snow begins to fall softly one night, Mabel remembers playing in it as a girl.
Before we know it, she and Jack are outside, throwing snowballs and building a snowman. No, a snow girl. With red mittens and scarf, a pretty face carved by Jack, and lips reddened by a berry. Yellow grass hair is the last touch.
The next morning, the snow has melted and Jack glimpses a figure with yellow hair and a red scarf, dashing through the trees.
When Mabel remembers the Russian folktale her father used to read them about a childless old couple who made a snow child that came to life, she writes to her sister to ask for the old book.
As Jack finally tracks her and coaxes her to come closer to the cabin, we see Faina is like a lovely wild animal. Shy of them but fierce and capable of looking after herself in ways they can’t.
“The child brought the smell of snow in with her, and the air in the cabin cooled and brightened.”
As they begin to interact, Mabel keeps re-reading the story and her sister’s letter with more details of the folktale. She becomes frightened, understanding that such a child may not survive.
“Another child gone from their lives. It was a possibility she could not bear. She wound herself tightly, as if within her girdled ribs she could contain all possibilities, all futures and all deaths. Perhaps if she held herself just right. Maybe if she knew what would be or could be. Or if she wished with enough heart. If only she could believe.”
Haven’t we all done that? Prayed, crossed fingers, collected lucky charms, “wound ourselves tightly”?
Ivey has written a magical story, and it even includes a possible explanation for Faina’s presence. But we don’t really buy that, do we? We like the fairy tale. And this is a magical place.
“Illumination behind the peaks shot up into shards of light, blue-green like a dying fire, rippled and twisted, then spun circles into ribbons of purple that stretched up and over Mabel’s head until she heard an electric crackle like the sparks from a wool blanket in a dry cabin at night. She looked directly up into the northern lights and she wondered if those cold-burning specters might not draw her breath, her very soul, out of her chest and into the stars.”
“It was beautiful, Mabel knew, but it was a beauty that ripped you open and scoured you clean so that you were left helpless and exposed, if you lived at all.
. . .
Jack had always scoffed at the superstitious and mystical. Alone in the depths of the wilderness, however, in the fading winter light, he had discovered in himself an animal-like fear.”
A debut, a Pulitzer Prize nominee, and a wonderful story I’m happy to add to my list of favourites. I used to read myths and fairy tales, so I’m a perfect audience for this lovely interpretation of an old Russian folktale.
It's 1920, Wolverine River, Alaska. Jack and Mabel have made a daring move from the comfortable East Coast of the United States. Mabel was a well-educated, sheltered girl, but when she and Jack lost their baby and have had none since, she urged him to make the change. They needed to start anew, by themselves, for themselves. Or so she told people.
“. . . she wondered if she had told the truth. Was that why they had come north – to build a life? Or did fear drive her? Fear of the gray, not just in the strands of her hair and her wilting cheeks, but the gray that ran deeper, to the bone, so that she thought she might turn into a fine dust and simply sift away in the wind.”
Eventually the isolation, Jack’s troubles trying to farm, and their dwindling finances finally grind Mabel down, not to a fine dust, but to a state of despair.
She’s ready to call it quits, but then one day, they meet a neighbour family of lively boys and colourful parents, and they are sucked into their warm circle. Esther is a strong, loveable woman in overalls with a never-say-die attitude. Just what Mabel needs.
“Esther burst into the cabin like a friendly hen, flapping and chattering and nearly knocking Mabel over as she tried to open the door for her. In one hand she held a towel-covered cast-iron pot and with the other she hugged Mabel and kissed her on the cheek.”
When the snow begins to fall softly one night, Mabel remembers playing in it as a girl.
Before we know it, she and Jack are outside, throwing snowballs and building a snowman. No, a snow girl. With red mittens and scarf, a pretty face carved by Jack, and lips reddened by a berry. Yellow grass hair is the last touch.
The next morning, the snow has melted and Jack glimpses a figure with yellow hair and a red scarf, dashing through the trees.
When Mabel remembers the Russian folktale her father used to read them about a childless old couple who made a snow child that came to life, she writes to her sister to ask for the old book.
As Jack finally tracks her and coaxes her to come closer to the cabin, we see Faina is like a lovely wild animal. Shy of them but fierce and capable of looking after herself in ways they can’t.
“The child brought the smell of snow in with her, and the air in the cabin cooled and brightened.”
As they begin to interact, Mabel keeps re-reading the story and her sister’s letter with more details of the folktale. She becomes frightened, understanding that such a child may not survive.
“Another child gone from their lives. It was a possibility she could not bear. She wound herself tightly, as if within her girdled ribs she could contain all possibilities, all futures and all deaths. Perhaps if she held herself just right. Maybe if she knew what would be or could be. Or if she wished with enough heart. If only she could believe.”
Haven’t we all done that? Prayed, crossed fingers, collected lucky charms, “wound ourselves tightly”?
Ivey has written a magical story, and it even includes a possible explanation for Faina’s presence. But we don’t really buy that, do we? We like the fairy tale. And this is a magical place.
“Illumination behind the peaks shot up into shards of light, blue-green like a dying fire, rippled and twisted, then spun circles into ribbons of purple that stretched up and over Mabel’s head until she heard an electric crackle like the sparks from a wool blanket in a dry cabin at night. She looked directly up into the northern lights and she wondered if those cold-burning specters might not draw her breath, her very soul, out of her chest and into the stars.”
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The Snow Child.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
January 23, 2017
– Shelved
June 20, 2018
–
Started Reading
June 20, 2018
–
24.61%
"This has all the makings of a new favourite, but it's probably a bit early to call it. (I hope not.)"
page
95
June 22, 2018
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-41 of 41 (41 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Matt
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jun 27, 2018 04:45AM
Brilliant review, Patty!!
reply
|
flag
Matt wrote: "Brilliant review, Patty!!"
Thanks, Matt. I know I cheated a bit with Equinox challenge in the Book For All Seasons group, but it was SO wintry (which is your season).
Thanks, Matt. I know I cheated a bit with Equinox challenge in the Book For All Seasons group, but it was SO wintry (which is your season).
Angela M wrote: "Wonderful, Patty ! This book made me sad and I swear I felt cold !"
Thanks, and likewise, Angela! I'm not sure I've felt that cold since I read Burial Rites.
Thanks, and likewise, Angela! I'm not sure I've felt that cold since I read Burial Rites.
Rae wrote: "Read this one long ago, Loved it!! So glad you liked it too Patty."
Thanks, Rae. It’s been on my list for a while, especially after I read her second one, To the Bright Edge of the World, which I also loved. What a talent, eh?
Thanks, Rae. It’s been on my list for a while, especially after I read her second one, To the Bright Edge of the World, which I also loved. What a talent, eh?
Excellent review, Patty! I've never read it. The story sounds intriguing. I might have to give it a try.
Carolyn wrote: "Lovely review Patty!
I still have to read her second but sounds like I should :)"
Thanks - It’s another one that might make you feel pretty chilly, Carolyn.
I still have to read her second but sounds like I should :)"
Thanks - It’s another one that might make you feel pretty chilly, Carolyn.
Candace wrote: "Excellent review, Patty! I've never read it. The story sounds intriguing. I might have to give it a try."
Thanks. I often don’t especially like prize-winners, but this one is lovely and readable!
Thanks. I often don’t especially like prize-winners, but this one is lovely and readable!
Can't say I was ever into myths & fairy tales so I may not appreciate this the way you did but I really enjoyed your review thanks Patty.
Sharon wrote: "Can't say I was ever into myths & fairy tales so I may not appreciate this the way you did but I really enjoyed your review thanks Patty."
You have to suspend a bit of disbelief, but there IS a possible real explanation for the child, too. And it’s beautifully written, of course!
You have to suspend a bit of disbelief, but there IS a possible real explanation for the child, too. And it’s beautifully written, of course!
Rita wrote: "Wow, Patty, great review! This book was already on my wtr list and now I can't wait to read it."
I hope you enjoy following their tale as much as I did, Rita. Thanks!
I hope you enjoy following their tale as much as I did, Rita. Thanks!
I read this and gave it only two stars. I guess I'm not fond of fairy tales?
I would think that the author would have filled in the blanks, i.e., she would have made the fairy tale seem more realistic by showing how the unrealistic might really have happened. And she does seem to be trying to do that. But the reader still needs a willing suspension of disbelief. The book is full of unanswered questions.
I would think that the author would have filled in the blanks, i.e., she would have made the fairy tale seem more realistic by showing how the unrealistic might really have happened. And she does seem to be trying to do that. But the reader still needs a willing suspension of disbelief. The book is full of unanswered questions.
Amalia wrote: "Absolutely beautiful review, Patty!! This is one of my most beloved books and I am so so so happy you loved it!"
I'm sure your review was one that prompted me to move it up my list. I also have a soft spot for folktales and interesting beliefs. And thanks!
I'm sure your review was one that prompted me to move it up my list. I also have a soft spot for folktales and interesting beliefs. And thanks!
Beth wrote: "I read this and gave it only two stars. I guess I'm not fond of fairy tales?
I would think that the author would have filled in the blanks, i.e., she would have made the fairy tale seem more real..."
You might be happy with actual fairy tales, Beth, but this is a kind of mixture, I think. I know I often compare stories like this with my favourite old Twilight Zone episodes, many of which were based on a kind of "what if?" premise. What if this child came to life - what would happen then?
The possible real explanation the author gave may have been made to appease Jack's (as well as our) scepticism. I sometimes like loose ends, myself, but I understand why you might not. :)
I would think that the author would have filled in the blanks, i.e., she would have made the fairy tale seem more real..."
You might be happy with actual fairy tales, Beth, but this is a kind of mixture, I think. I know I often compare stories like this with my favourite old Twilight Zone episodes, many of which were based on a kind of "what if?" premise. What if this child came to life - what would happen then?
The possible real explanation the author gave may have been made to appease Jack's (as well as our) scepticism. I sometimes like loose ends, myself, but I understand why you might not. :)
Faith wrote: "Lovely review, Patty! I'm fond of updated versions of fairy tales. Will look this one up."
It's terrific, Faith, and thanks! I don't think you'll be disappointed. I was glad so many GR reviewers mentioned it, or I might never have found it myself.
It's terrific, Faith, and thanks! I don't think you'll be disappointed. I was glad so many GR reviewers mentioned it, or I might never have found it myself.
Jennifer (Jen/The Tolkien Gal) wrote: "Breathtaking review, Patty. I really want to read this book!"
Thanks, Jen- it's the book that's breathtaking, almost literally when you start to feel the cold!
Thanks, Jen- it's the book that's breathtaking, almost literally when you start to feel the cold!
Brilliant review, Patty! This sound very intreguing! May have to check it out! =o)
I'm not supposed to be adding books, Patty! You're not helping! LOL I'm just teasing you! 😁
I'm not supposed to be adding books, Patty! You're not helping! LOL I'm just teasing you! 😁
Li'l Owl wrote: "Brilliant review, Patty! This sound very intreguing! May have to check it out! =o)
I'm not supposed to be adding books, Patty! You're not helping! LOL I'm just teasing you! 😁"
Thanks! That means my temptation work is done, Owl! Seriously, it's a Pulitzer AND it's a good read. (Not all of them are for me.)
I'm not supposed to be adding books, Patty! You're not helping! LOL I'm just teasing you! 😁"
Thanks! That means my temptation work is done, Owl! Seriously, it's a Pulitzer AND it's a good read. (Not all of them are for me.)
PattyMacDotComma wrote: "Rae wrote: "Read this one long ago, Loved it!! So glad you liked it too Patty."
Thanks, Rae. It’s been on my list for a while, especially after I read her second one, [book:To the Bright Edge of t..."
Well now I'm going to have to look into reading her second one. Her writing is beautiful. Thanks for the recommendation, Patty.
Thanks, Rae. It’s been on my list for a while, especially after I read her second one, [book:To the Bright Edge of t..."
Well now I'm going to have to look into reading her second one. Her writing is beautiful. Thanks for the recommendation, Patty.
Rae wrote: "PattyMacDotComma wrote: "Rae wrote: "Read this one long ago, Loved it!! So glad you liked it too Patty."
Thanks, Rae. It’s been on my list for a while, especially after I read her second one, [boo..."
I hope you like it too, Rae. It's got a more historical background to it, but for me, that just added to the atmosphere and the challenge of living there then. (Not that it's easy now, I suspect!)
Thanks, Rae. It’s been on my list for a while, especially after I read her second one, [boo..."
I hope you like it too, Rae. It's got a more historical background to it, but for me, that just added to the atmosphere and the challenge of living there then. (Not that it's easy now, I suspect!)
Jen wrote: "I need to still get to this one, too. Great review, Patty!"
Thanks, Jen. I did postpone it, but it’s one that was worth bumping up!
Thanks, Jen. I did postpone it, but it’s one that was worth bumping up!
Janice wrote: "Your review took me back to this wonderful story, and why I loved it!"
Oh, I'm so glad, Janice! It's one reason I write reviews - so I can remind MYSELF of a book and what I did or didn't like.
Oh, I'm so glad, Janice! It's one reason I write reviews - so I can remind MYSELF of a book and what I did or didn't like.
Jean wrote: "A lovely review of a lovely book!"
Thanks, Jean. This one really can make even the most doubting believe in magic - or at least want to!
Thanks, Jean. This one really can make even the most doubting believe in magic - or at least want to!