Sign in with Facebook
Kendall's Reviews > Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine
Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine
by
by
I feel like this book is a bit difficult for me to review.
I'm wondering if I would have enjoyed this book more if I wasn't a social worker? I realized that unfortunately I just can't read books about child welfare system anymore since I'm so experienced with this stuff.
I found my attention span wavering in and out due to the nature of the story. But, I can definitely see how others would rate this so highly. I am glad that I was able to experience something by Gail Honeyman!
I'm wondering if I would have enjoyed this book more if I wasn't a social worker? I realized that unfortunately I just can't read books about child welfare system anymore since I'm so experienced with this stuff.
I found my attention span wavering in and out due to the nature of the story. But, I can definitely see how others would rate this so highly. I am glad that I was able to experience something by Gail Honeyman!
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Comments Showing 1-39 of 39 (39 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Jaline
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jul 10, 2017 10:00PM
I do understand your quandary, Kendall. I used to be a clinical counselor and there are times I want to jump into the story and sort everyone out - lol. If I can catch myself soon enough I can usually distance what I know from what's going on in the book. Other times, it's nigh impossible. :)
reply
|
flag
Sorry this one was not for you Kendall but I can understand why. Hope your next one is better.
Sorry this wasn't the right one for you Kendall. I understand how you look at books like this through different eyes. Hope your next read is a 5* for you!
Hopefully your next read will be better suited 😍
Sorry this wasn't a better one for you Kendall. I hope your next one is so much better! :-)
Kendall...I think your analysis is correct. I'm sure you did see Eleanor within the context of your job experience.
Shame you didn't enjoy it more Kendall.
Too bad this wasn't better for you Kendall. I can completely understand how your reading experience would have been largely affected by your professional experience. I hope your next book is fantastic!! :-)
I definitely understand your need to separate your professional life from your reading! I try to stay clear of any books that has to do with my business - reading is my escape!! Thanks for the honest review :)
An honest review- thanks Kendall
Hi Jaline- yes I just found that to keep myself sane lol I need to avoid reading subject matter alongside my job. I can't be surrounded by it all the time.
Thank you Mary, Kaceey, Miriam, Norma, Fran, Maureen!
Lindsay- thank you Lindsay! I'm just glad I did experience this and can now really understand my limits with certain books. I hope you enjoy it!
Marilyn- That's EXACTLY what it is Marilyn. You said it so perfectly! It's a stress reliever for me and I can't escape with books that are my profession. I'm glad you feel the same :). Jen- thank you! :)
Good review Kendall; hope your next book is a winner !
Thank you Frances!
Kendall,I've just finished it and loved it! I understand what you're saying about having a different perspective on it because you're a social worker. Probably too related to work to be seen as a book read for pleasure.
I can understand why this wouldn't be an enjoyable read for you, Kendall. I applaud you for finishing it. THANK YOU for the wonderful contribution you give to humanity.
Thank you Mary. Yeah a lot of people loved it. Glad you did.Linda- aww thank you so much for that sweet comment! Yes it's nice to hear that... sometimes social workers unfortunately are associated with negative connotations a lot.
You're a social worker! Wow, your work is sooo hard and so beautiful! BTW, Great review Kendall! 💗
Great review, Kendall! I want to echo what Linda said. You have a very important job and it's definitely under-recognized. Thank you! :)
Thank you Nazanin and Jennifer! Yes my job is very hard! But thank you for the sweet and kind words!
Kendall, I too am a social worker and thought the same thing. I'm yet to finish but I think it will get a three from me too.
Hey Susie! Yeah just can't mix my reading and career 🙅. Sounds like we maybe have similar thoughts haha.
Kendall, thanks for posting such a candid review. It's truly appreciated.
Hi Ladonna! Thanks for the comment :). And your welcome!
Great review, Kendall. I can understand how that would be an issue. :/
I get it, I'm a nurse and often feel the same way about medical themed books.
Thanks Jan! Glad someone can relate haha ;).
Bummer! Sorry you weren't able to enjoy this one, Kendall.
Thanks Melissa. Hopefully you enjoy it better then me!
I'm sorry it didn't work out for you, Kendall. I hope your next read is a great one :)
Thanks so much Deanna :)
Sorry it didn't work for Kendall! Good that it helped you realize your limits. I have just recognized what mine are and what to avoid to keep the chatter out of my head. lol
Hahahaha Brenda! Yes I definitely know my limits now. And exactly I'm done with the chatter in my head lol.
That's very honest of you Kendall!
Thank you so much Louise :)
Sorry this one wasn't for you, Kendall!
